First posted on Instagram
Attorney General Todd Blanche has vowed to take any Democratic effort to enact the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact to the United States Supreme Court, calling the plan to bypass the Electoral College a blatant violation of the Constitution. The warning came after the November 3 midterm elections handed Democrats unified control of state government in Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, Arizona and Nevada — five states holding 61 electoral votes between them, more than enough to push the compact past the 270-vote threshold it needs to take effect before the 2028 presidential election.
What is at stake is how the next president is chosen. Under the compact, each member state would award all of its electoral votes to the candidate who wins the national popular vote, even if that candidate lost the vote inside the state itself. Once states holding 270 electoral votes have joined, the compact activates — and the Electoral College would remain on paper while the national popular vote decided the presidency in practice. For voters in smaller and rural states, that would mean presidential campaigns fought almost entirely in the biggest cities; for supporters, it would mean every vote counts the same wherever it is cast.
“I have FULL confidence that if they try this maneuver, it’ll be STOPPED immediately. But YES, we WILL take it to the Supreme Court if we have to, because this would be a blatant VIOLATION of the Constitution!” Blanche said, in remarks reported over the weekend. “By the way, it shouldn’t even need to get to the Supreme Court. It shouldn’t get past the district court... if there is a judge in this country that would even let this happen for a minute, we have a big problem.”
The arithmetic is what changed. For years the compact sat at 222 electoral votes — 18 states and the District of Columbia, 48 short of the 270 needed to activate — and it stayed there because the states that would supply the rest were divided. The midterms removed that obstacle: Michigan, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin and Nevada together hold 50 electoral votes, enough on their own to carry the compact to 272, and Arizona’s 11 would take it to 283. The National Popular Vote organisation, which wrote the compact and campaigns for it state by state, told Fox News Digital it has identified legislative sponsors in each of the five states and expects bills to be pre-filed before, or introduced early in, the 2027 legislative sessions.
The compact’s backers say the Constitution already gives them the power. They point to Article II, Section 1, which leaves it to each state legislature to decide how its electors are appointed, and argue that states which already award electors on a winner-take-all basis are free to pledge them to the national popular vote winner instead. Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant for National Popular Vote, told Fox News Digital: “I am confident we have multiple paths to secure the 48 electoral votes required.”
The critics answer in the same breath that the plan cannot survive a court challenge. Hans von Spakovsky, an election law expert with the conservative group Advancing American Freedom and a former commissioner on the Federal Election Commission, told Fox News Digital: “They can’t use a compact to, in essence, change the Electoral College. This is unprecedented. In the past, the only kind of compacts that have been agreed on between states have been things like water sharing... But a compact that changes a fundamental structural given in the Constitution, I think the Supreme Court would say you can’t do that.” Von Spakovsky added that states choosing not to join the compact would have a strong basis for litigation, and that the case would end up in the Supreme Court on the argument that the compact is unconstitutional because it changes a fundamental structural part of the Constitution without going through the amendment process.
The legal fight would turn on two provisions the courts have never applied to a compact like this one. The first is the Compact Clause of Article I, Section 10, which says no state shall enter into any agreement or compact with another state without the consent of Congress — and opponents argue a pact that rewires presidential elections plainly encroaches on federal power. The second is Article II itself: in Chiafalo v. Washington in 2020, the Supreme Court upheld a state’s power to bind its electors to the outcome of its own state’s vote, but it has never decided whether a state may bind its electors to the votes of people in other states. The Washington Post reported on Sunday that opponents of the plan are prepared to sue the moment a new state signs on.
Blanche, 52, is the 88th Attorney General of the United States. A former federal prosecutor in New York who served as President Donald Trump’s personal lawyer in three criminal cases, he joined the Justice Department in 2025 as deputy attorney general under Pam Bondi, led the department as acting attorney general after Trump removed Bondi in April, and was confirmed by the Senate on August 8 by 50 votes to 49. He has spent the weeks since the midterms warning the incoming Democratic majority in Congress that the Justice Department will not back down from its election-integrity cases, telling Fox News’ Hannity on November 9 that the department would defend its lawsuits over state voter rolls all the way to the Supreme Court if necessary.
The compact was designed by computer scientist John Koza and first enacted by Maryland in 2007. It has been gathering states ever since, almost entirely Democratic-run ones, and its backers have always said the hard part was finding the last 48 electoral votes. The midterms handed them a path to those votes in a single legislative session. What happens next is a race: bills are expected in the five state capitals early in 2027, and any state that passes one can expect a lawsuit the same week, with the case climbing toward the Supreme Court well before Americans vote for president in 2028.