First posted on Instagram
The Chicago City Council voted 45-5 on Wednesday to order an independent review of Mayor Brandon Johnson's handling of the city's finances, escalating a budget fight that burst into the open five days earlier when his chief financial officer quit, saying she could not stay in the job without compromising her integrity.
The review reaches into the numbers behind a $17.6 billion budget plan that must close an $882 million shortfall — the money that pays for police, schools, streets and pensions in the nation's third-largest city — and it comes as Wall Street has put Chicago's credit rating on watch for a possible downgrade, a step that would raise the cost of borrowing for everything the city builds and fixes.
The ordinance, introduced by Finance Committee Chair Ald. Pat Dowell and 11 colleagues, authorises Dowell to hire an outside firm to conduct what the measure calls an "independent, impartial and comprehensive review" of whether any material or intentional misstatements about the city's financial condition were made to investors, the City Council or the public in any document, presentation, offering or financial reporting in the past three years. The firm would report to Dowell, not to the mayor, and could demand records from any city employee.
The five votes against came from Alds. William Hall, David Moore, Byron Sigcho-Lopez, Jason Ervin — the Council's Budget Committee chair and one of Johnson's closest allies — and Rossana Rodriguez-Sanchez. The measure needed 34 votes to survive a possible veto by the mayor; it cleared that bar by 11.
The vote followed the abrupt resignation on Friday, November 13, of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, who had held the job for about three months after a career at Fitch Ratings. She is the third person to leave the post in under a year, after Jill Jaworski and Steven Mahr. In her resignation statement, first reported by the Chicago Tribune, Gabrysch wrote that there was nothing more important for a chief financial officer than her fiduciary duty to the city and its taxpayers, and that the officer's statements about city finances "are relied upon by investors, ratings agencies, City Council and taxpayers" and "must be accurate and complete." She added: "It has become apparent, however, that to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligations."
The dispute at the centre of the fight is over how much of Johnson's budget plan is a lasting fix. In his budget address last month, Johnson said 76% of his proposals for closing the $882 million shortfall were structural — permanent changes rather than one-time measures. At the Council's first budget hearing on October 26, Gabrysch told aldermen the real figure was 56%, because the plan counted borrowing to cover police misconduct settlements as a structural fix. She later emailed top mayoral aides that the 76% figure was "not a truthful statement to investors" in a pending city bond deal, the Chicago Sun-Times reported. In a guest opinion piece in the Tribune on Monday, she gave her first detailed public account of why she walked away. Her own math put the shortfall nearer $1 billion once added costs were counted, against the $882 million Johnson cited in September and an adjusted $652.5 million figure he offered in October.
Johnson has denied asking anyone to misrepresent the city's finances. At his first City Hall news conference since the resignation, on Tuesday, he said he had done nothing wrong and welcomed scrutiny. "As I said before, I welcome any audit or investigation. We welcome all of it," he said. After Wednesday's vote, a mayor's office spokesperson said "the administration welcomes an independent audit of the City's finances in accordance with professionally accepted standards for municipal finance." The administration has also pushed back on Gabrysch, saying she was "largely absent during critical periods of the city's budget preparation process" and directed the City Treasurer to issue a $75 million payment without proper legal authority. Gabrysch has said the only meetings she missed were conferences approved by the mayor's chief of staff. The $75 million — money from the new owners of the parking-meter system — was voted 44-6 by the Council on November 2 to go toward the city's pension funds.
What happens next is still open. Dowell must choose a firm to carry out the review, and no timeline has been announced. The review is unlikely to produce findings before the Council's final budget negotiations, and the Council must pass a 2027 budget by December 31 to avoid a shutdown; 28 aldermen have already called the mayor's plan a non-starter over its corporate head tax and higher lease tax. On Wednesday, S&P Global Ratings placed Chicago on credit watch, warning the city's credit rating could be downgraded within 90 days and citing Gabrysch's resignation. Ald. Bill Conway has separately asked the Inspector General to investigate the circumstances of her resignation, while the mayor's office has asked the same office to look at the $75 million payment. Comptroller Michael Belsky, who is serving as acting chief financial officer — the city's fourth finance chief this year — has dismissed Gabrysch's objections as "much ado about nothing." Dowell has said bringing Gabrysch to testify at a public hearing is not off the table.
In the same special meeting, the Council voted unanimously, 50-0, for a resolution pressing Gov. JB Pritzker and Illinois lawmakers to amend the state constitution to allow a millionaires tax — a question Chicago voters backed overwhelmingly in the November 3 midterm ballot questions, along with a corporate head tax on businesses with 500 or more employees.