First posted on Instagram
Elon Musk arrived in China with President Donald Trump on Wednesday, travelling with the president into Shenzhen for the APEC summit, where China's Xi Jinping broke with protocol and waited at the foot of Air Force One's stairs to greet Trump in person. Musk, the head of Tesla and SpaceX, is the main chief executive travelling with Trump, U.S. officials have said, and he will take part in some events around the summit — but he will not sit in the room when Trump meets Xi and Russia's Vladimir Putin on Thursday.
For American households, the four days in Shenzhen are the week the price of the technology inside their phones, cars and computers gets negotiated in person. The meetings will decide whether the United States tightens its curbs on the advanced AI chips China can buy, whether Washington and Beijing finally build the emergency hotline for AI incidents they agreed to in September, and whether the three largest nuclear powers can restart arms talks nine months after the last U.S.-Russia treaty expired. What is settled in that room reaches American factories, data centres and energy bills — and what is not settled leaves the chip supply chain, and the nuclear arsenals, exactly where they are.
Xi's welcome was the gesture of the day. According to CNN and NPR, Xi waited at the bottom of the aircraft's stairs at Shenzhen Bao'an International Airport before greeting Trump with a handshake that developed into an embrace, with a guard of honour and military aircraft on the tarmac. CNN noted that Xi had not personally welcomed an American president at the airport during his term in office. Putin, who arrived in Shenzhen earlier on Wednesday, was greeted instead by Cai Qi, a senior Chinese Communist Party official. Xinhua, cited by The Guardian, reported that Xi told Trump he wanted a "constructive, strategic and stable" relationship founded on "respect, fairness and reciprocity". Trump said the talks would cover "many things, including denuclearization."
The welcome stands in contrast to the trip Musk is making. A senior U.S. official told reporters on Friday that Musk would travel with Trump and could act as an adviser to the president, adding: "Obviously, he has tremendous business interests in the U.S.-China relationship." The White House has not explained Musk's role beyond that, and officials told the Associated Press that Musk will not join the three-way meeting. Jonathan Czin, a former National Security Council director for China, read Musk's presence as a signal about the administration's priorities. The APEC CEO Summit, running November 17–18, drew more than 2,000 political and business leaders, and the guest list for the summit dinner includes the heads of Mastercard and FedEx.
One correction to the way the news travelled on social media: the question hanging over the trip — can China and the United States avoid the "Thucydides Trap", the slide into conflict when a rising power threatens an established one — was posed by Xi himself, not by Musk. Xi asked Trump the question when the two met in Beijing in May, and the term was popularised by the Harvard political scientist Graham Allison. What Musk brings to Shenzhen is not a warning of his own but his companies' stake in the relationship: Tesla builds and sells cars in China, and SpaceX's Starlink sits at the centre of the technology contest the summit is meant to manage.
Before Shenzhen there was Manila. Trump flew in from the Philippines, where he attended the ASEAN summit and the Quad leaders' meeting and announced a trade deal with the Philippines that, as reported, carries no published terms and nothing signed. The White House's own account of the departure said the ASEAN-U.S. summit, the Quad meeting and the trade deals were done, and added: "Next stop: Shenzhen, China, where @POTUS will attend the APEC summit and hold key meetings with President Xi and President Putin."
The chip question follows Trump into the room. The departure of Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang, after reports of an affair with a woman U.S. intelligence suspects was a Chinese spy, has sharpened the AI file, and officials said Trump does not plan to raise the Nvidia allegations with Xi. The meeting with Xi is the third between the two leaders this year, two months after Xi was hosted at the White House, and the trade truce between the two countries has been extended until January 2027.
What happens next is Thursday in Shenzhen. Trump holds a bilateral meeting and working lunch with Xi, and at 2:30 p.m. local time the three leaders sit down together at the Shenzhen Kylin Villa — the first time the heads of state of the United States, China and Russia have ever met in person. Nuclear arms cuts and the war in Iran were billed as the agenda; Trump added Ukraine on Monday, reversing the line his own officials gave on Friday that it would stay off the table. The White House has said no agreement is expected from the meeting, and China confirmed on Monday that Xi will host it, calling the first-ever gathering groundbreaking in significance.