A federal judge in Boston ruled on Thursday that the Trump administration cannot bar health care providers receiving Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program funds from acknowledging the gender identity of their transgender patients or from providing them gender-affirming care. U.S. District Judge William Young issued a 165-page ruling after a bench trial in September, siding with a group of national HIV medical associations and health care providers that challenged grant funding conditions the administration imposed last year.
Why it matters: the Ryan White program, created by Congress in 1990, pays for medical care for low-income and uninsured people living with HIV. The conditions would have forced providers to choose between federal funding and treating transgender patients as they are — using their names and pronouns and providing care the doctors say their patients need. Young's ruling keeps the money flowing without that choice, and it does so on First Amendment grounds, which reach beyond this one program to any federal funding condition that penalises a provider for what it says to a patient.
The conditions at issue came from the Health Resources and Services Administration, the division of the Department of Health and Human Services that administers the Ryan White program. Beginning in March, the agency added funding conditions designed to carry out President Donald Trump's executive order prohibiting federal funding for what he calls "gender ideology" and directing the government to recognise only two sexes, male and female. The new conditions required providers to ensure funding would support activities using "sex-based definitions grounded in biological reality" and not "social or medical experimentation," according to the lawsuit.
Young said the conditions were designed to suppress what the administration considered to be "dangerous ideas," in violation of the First Amendment, by penalising doctors for acknowledging that transgender people exist and referring to their patients by their preferred pronouns, Reuters reported. The lawsuit, filed in June by groups including the American Academy of HIV Medicine, also argued the policy violated the Administrative Procedure Act, the federal law governing how agencies make, change and repeal regulations.
The administration's position is that the conditions carry out the president's executive order, which bars federal money from supporting what the order calls gender ideology. Young, who was appointed by Republican President Ronald Reagan, urged the administration at the end of the September trial to settle the case. The administration rejected a settlement proposal from the plaintiffs, according to an October 2 court filing, and the case went to judgment instead.
What happens next: the ruling blocks the conditions, so providers in the Ryan White program can continue acknowledging transgender patients and providing gender-affirming care without losing federal funds. The administration can appeal to the First Circuit, and the case is one of several court fights over the executive order's funding restrictions still moving through the courts.