The first large national study of school cellphone bans has found that strict bans work: students at schools that lock phones away all day gained the equivalent of one to two extra weeks of instruction a year in math and reading. The study, from Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research with NWEA and Dartmouth researchers, tracked 3.3 million students in grades 3 through 10 at 4,600 schools.
Why it matters: American scores have been sliding since about 2013, the years smartphones took over childhood — nearly a whole grade level lost in eighth-grade math and reading. The ban hands back about half of that yearly slide, and cheaply: the lockable pouches cost about $425 a classroom. For families under bans in 40 states and Washington, D.C., it is the first hard evidence the policy gives learning back.
How the phone is stored decides whether it works. Schools that locked phones in pouches or a central place got the gains; schools that let students keep them in backpacks did not. The most distractible students gained most in reading. "What our results suggest today is, yes, cell phones in schools are having a negative impact," said the lead researcher, Harvard economist Thomas Kane.
The students have come around. At Baldwin High School on Long Island, where phones sit locked away bell to bell under New York's law, junior William Scott said his first reaction was dread — "I'm gonna be bored in class" — but "now that they're banned, it's much easier to focus on my classes." Classmate Christine Addai: "When you're not on your phone, you can really grasp it more."
Someone had to start it. Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed the first law in the nation in May 2023. NYU psychologist Jonathan Haidt gave the movement its argument — his 2023 essay "The Case for Phone-Free Schools" and his book The Anxious Generation, which Arkansas Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders sent to every legislator in her state. New York Governor Kathy Hochul carried it furthest, making New York the largest bell-to-bell state.
The researchers are honest that one year's gain is small. Their next question is larger: what social media outside school does to the same students. But the direction is now measured, not guessed, and the gain builds year after year. With most states already in, the country will learn whether locked-away phones keep giving the learning back.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here