The Justice Department secretly demanded 18 months of LinkedIn records for six journalists' accounts in a leak investigation, with a one-year gag order barring LinkedIn from telling anyone, including the journalists and their employer, that it existed. On November 10, a unanimous three-judge panel of the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the demand "substantially overbroad" and ordered it narrowed.
The ruling checks the government's power to sweep up reporters' private contacts to find a leaker. The journalists had published nearly 1,000 articles in the 18 months covered, and fewer than 5 percent touched the leak under investigation — meaning the order would have handed investigators a map of almost every confidential source the reporters spoke to.
The case is In re: Application, No. 26-4303. Judge J. Harvie Wilkinson III wrote the opinion for the panel. The government obtained two orders under the Stored Communications Act: one requiring LinkedIn to disclose the metadata, another barring it from informing anyone for a year. LinkedIn challenged both. A magistrate judge and District Judge Elizabeth Hanes sided with the government in June. The appeals court held LinkedIn had standing, the disclosure order violated statutory and constitutional norms, and the secrecy order was an overly broad prior restraint that must be narrowed so LinkedIn can notify a single vetted attorney for the news outlet.
The case centers on freelance journalist Matthew Cole, one of two journalists bylined on a September 5, 2025 New York Times article about a failed 2019 SEAL Team 6 mission in North Korea that killed unarmed civilians. Five months after publication, the Justice Department subpoenaed Cole to name his confidential sources before a grand jury; a magistrate judge recommended in July that his motion to quash be denied. The department also sought subscriber information and call records from AT&T for a mobile account believed to be Cole's, and told his lawyers on November 12 that it had not received the LinkedIn records.
Cole's lawyers asked to postpone a hearing set for Thursday, November 19, in Virginia before Judge Mark Davis, arguing the ruling raises questions about the government keeping the demands secret. The Justice Department opposed a delay, saying it would hamper the investigation. If Judge Davis adopts that recommendation, Cole could face a choice between naming his sources and risking fines or jail. The department can still seek a narrower order.