First posted on Instagram
Fox News host Laura Ingraham has rejected former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's claim that Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin "play" President Donald Trump, arguing that sitting down with both leaders at the same time is essential for American interests and global diplomacy. Clinton made the remark on journalist Kara Swisher's podcast on November 18, as Trump arrived in Shenzhen for the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit and a first-ever trilateral meeting with Xi and Putin; Ingraham answered it the same day, interrupting Trump's live Fox News interview from China to ask him why meeting both men together was an advantage.
The exchange goes to the heart of the Shenzhen summit, the first time the leaders of the United States, Russia and China have sat together to hash out global issues. The talks were expected to cover nuclear weapons limits, the war in Ukraine, the war in Iran, trade tensions and artificial intelligence — questions whose answers reach American households through energy prices, trade and the cost of the wars the United States is entangled in. How the meeting is judged will shape whether the public sees the diplomacy as strength or concession.
Clinton's words were blunt. "All he cares about, the best I can tell, is looking like he belongs in the company of Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin," she said on Swisher's podcast. "These two men play him like a child's guitar. It is pathetic. A child's, not a Stradivarius. A child's guitar." She predicted the meeting would produce nothing for the United States: "When [Trump] came out of the meeting with Xi and the United States, there was nothing to report! He will fulminate, he will bluster, he'll make these ridiculous claims, we will get nothing of importance to our national security or economic security." She added: "I think it will weaken us. It will give Putin and Xi more control over him."
Ingraham's answer was that refusing to engage would be the mistake. Her argument is that the United States should recognise its differences with China and Russia while still seeking common ground through shared interests, and that walking away from the table would serve neither American economic interests nor national security. In the live interview from Shenzhen, she put the question to Trump directly: "Jacqui, just one question for the president before he goes on to meet with Xi and Putin: Why is it an advantage to meet with both men at the same time?" Trump replied that meeting both leaders together made sense, and said the discussions were expected to cover denuclearization and ending the war in Iran.
Clinton was not alone in her criticism. Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said on the Senate floor that "Xi and Putin know that if they stroke Trump's ego and distract him with pomp and circumstance, and flatter him a little bit, Trump will back down on the issues that matter most to Americans." Analysts who follow the countries have also said Trump's leverage abroad has thinned since the midterm elections, with former Obama administration official Kurt Tong saying, "They will view the president as somewhat weakened now."
The meeting itself went ahead as planned. Trump greeted Putin as his "friend" in front of reporters and dined with Xi at an APEC gala, and the three leaders held their first joint session on Thursday, November 19. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said no more than an hour had been allocated for the trilateral meeting, and no immediate deliverables were announced. What the session produces — on Ukraine, Iran, nuclear limits and the trade truce — will be the test of whether Clinton's prediction or Ingraham's defence holds.