On his return to China — the return leg of the exchange that brought Xi Jinping to Washington in September — President Donald Trump sat down separately this evening in Shenzhen with Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney and then Mexico's President Claudia Sheinbaum, on the margins of the APEC leaders' summit. The Carney conversation lasted just under twenty minutes, with Secretary of State Marco Rubio, Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, Trade Representative Jamieson Greer and chief of staff Stephen Miller in the room; it was the two leaders' first face-to-face since formal trade talks between their countries collapsed in August. Sheinbaum's was the brief pull-aside she had promised — "a very, very brief, bilateral meeting, just a greeting" — and she came out of it calling the encounter very good.
Why it matters is the trade pact underneath all of it. The Canada–United States–Mexico Agreement governs how cars, food, steel and energy move between the United States and its two neighbours, and its future decides prices at American checkout counters and shifts at factories on all three sides of the borders. Both neighbours say the same thing in plain words: renew the pact, and trade gets predictability and tariff relief; let it die, and every shipment becomes a negotiation.
The reason the pact is in limbo is a decision Washington already made. In July, the Trump administration chose not to renew the agreement. That choice triggered a rolling annual review that can run for up to ten years — and if the three countries cannot agree an extension by the end of it, the pact expires. Talks since then have gone nowhere: reports say Lutnick created an impasse in the Mexican talks last month and was blamed for the eleventh-hour breakdown with Canada in August, when each side accused the other of pushing last-minute changes. Carney has said Trump's team wanted to restrict Canada's ability to make trade deals with other countries, endanger Canada's protections for its language and culture, and keep hefty tariffs on some automobiles.
Carney's office put the evening's purpose in its own words: "The leaders discussed the work underway to reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement that would create good jobs, boost affordability, and fully respect Canada's languages, culture and sovereignty. They agreed to continue the work and to stay in close contact." Carney himself, at his news conference shortly before the meeting, was blunter about why a deal is hard: "The United States fundamentally changed its trade objectives and we are focused on getting the right deal for Canadians." Canada's trade relations south of the border, he said, are "much more complex" than its dealings with Beijing — where this week he closed a deal giving Canadian pork and seafood about $400 million of tariff relief while Washington's tariffs still stand.
Mexico arrives at the same table carrying a fresher pressure. Six days ago Trump wrote on Truth Social: "MEXICO MUST STOP THEM, NOW, and if they do not do so, the Tariffs on Mexico will be IMMEDIATELY DOUBLED" — the "them" being migrant caravans moving through southern Mexico. Sheinbaum answered the same day that no migrant caravan has reached the northern border since Trump took office in January 2025. The two neighbours have started coordinating without Washington in the room: Carney and Sheinbaum met each other in Shenzhen on Tuesday, and both left that meeting committed to renewing the three-country pact.
The contrast is the story. In his first term, Trump negotiated this agreement himself to replace NAFTA, and sold it as the best trade deal ever made. In his second, his administration has declined to renew it, put both partners under tariffs, and watched the two of them cut side deals — with China, and with each other — while they wait to learn what Washington will accept. Nothing was signed tonight, and no tariff came down. What happens next runs on two tracks: the negotiators, with Greer's stated aim of interim limited agreements by the end of the year, and the calendar — every year the review rolls on without an extension, the pact moves one year closer to expiring.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here