First posted on Instagram
A security study of Dominion voting machines kept under court seal for two years is circulating again, and its findings are stark: the machines used in Georgia and more than a dozen other states run on software unpatched since 2015, count votes from barcodes voters cannot read, and can be infected across a whole county from one compromised file on a USB stick.
University of Michigan computer scientist J. Alex Halderman and Auburn University's Drew Springall wrote the study after testing Dominion's ImageCast X machines as expert witnesses in the Curling v. Raffensperger voting-rights lawsuit in Georgia. They filed the 96-page report under seal on July 1, 2021; a federal judge allowed its release on June 14, 2023.
The most consequential finding is how ballots are counted. The machine prints the voter's choices in plain text alongside a QR code — but the scanners tallying votes ignore the text and count only the code, which voters cannot read. Changing only the code could alter votes no voter would spot.
The machines run Democracy Suite 5.5-A on Android 5.1.1, unpatched since 2015. The critical flaw is in how they load election definitions — files county workers copy from the central election system to every machine on USB sticks. A modified file can install malicious code with root privileges on every machine in the jurisdiction, without an attacker touching any of them.
The U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Agency confirmed the flaws in a June 2022 advisory, listing nine vulnerabilities in Dominion equipment used in at least 16 states; Dominion later produced updated software. Halderman stressed he knows of no evidence the flaws were exploited to change votes in past elections, and CISA said states' standard procedures would detect exploitation and in many cases prevent it. Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger said the state would not install the update until after the 2024 presidential election.
The study is circulating again as the Trump administration presses states on election security; Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin warned in August that voting machines relying on Chinese-made components create supply-chain risks. Halderman concluded Georgia voters had "greatly diminished grounds to be confident" their votes were secured.