First posted on Instagram
Senator Eric Schmitt of Missouri says he is prepared to stay in Washington “day and night” to push through President Donald Trump’s remaining nominations before the end of the year, with 22 federal judges still awaiting confirmation and more than 100 other nominees who could be confirmed together in a bulk package. Schmitt’s push is aimed at getting the appointments across the finish line before the next Congress takes over in January, when Democrats take control of the Senate and every unconfirmed nomination is returned to the president.
Why it matters is the bench itself. Federal judges serve for life, and the 22 pending seats will decide cases on immigration, regulation, elections and the reach of federal power for decades. The 100-plus executive nominees would run the agencies that set the rules households live with, from energy and labour to the environment. If the Senate leaves the posts unfilled, the new Democratic majority will be able to block them outright and hold the seats open, hoping for a Democratic president in 2028.
Schmitt has been sounding the alarm for days. Last week he said Republicans should leave “NO judicial appointment behind” in the roughly 50 days left of their majority, warning that Democrats “are going to block all of these” once they take over. His latest message, posted on Tuesday, raises the urgency: stay in the capital until the job is done, and move the executive nominees in a single en bloc package so the Senate can work through the backlog before the year-end deadline.
The numbers show how much is still on the table. The Senate has confirmed 58 of Trump’s second-term judicial nominees, including Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit on Monday by 51 to 46 and Anna St. John to the Fifth Circuit. Twenty-two were still awaiting action after those votes, according to a Reuters count, and about 196 nominations in total were still waiting as of Monday, including 168 executive-branch posts. Since the election, Republicans have confirmed only one civilian nominee, Alabama district judge Gregory Cook, who was confirmed 49 to 27 last Thursday.
Democrats answer that Republicans are breaking the Senate’s own rules to rush the judges through. Senator Dick Durbin, the committee’s top Democrat, said on Tuesday that Republicans have violated longstanding committee norms, holding nomination hearings less than two weeks apart, cutting the time to review nominees’ background questionnaires from 28 days to seven, and scheduling as many as eight nominees for a single hearing. “Republicans are in a mad scramble to confirm as many judicial nominees as possible before the Democrats take majority control of the Senate in January,” Durbin said. Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley has answered that Democrats did the same thing in the lame-duck session of 2024, when they confirmed 22 judges, and Majority Leader John Thune has called confirmations a top priority and promised more than 100 additional civilian nominees by the end of the year.
Some of the resistance is coming from Republicans themselves. In Arkansas, Senators John Boozman and Tom Cotton opposed the nomination of Lee Rudofsky to the Eighth Circuit, and the White House withdrew it on Tuesday, replacing him with J. Cody Hiland. In Texas, Senator John Cornyn has not signed the blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, the nominee for a Dallas federal trial court seat, so Gaiser cannot appear at Wednesday’s Judiciary Committee hearing. In Oklahoma, Senator Alan Armstrong withdrew his support for Zach West, and Senator Thom Tillis of North Carolina is backing him. The White House has said it expects all pending judicial nominees to be confirmed this year, but Tillis answered: “That is not how it works here.”
One limit on the bulk plan is that the judges cannot ride along with it. Under the rule change Republicans adopted in September, most executive-branch nominees can be considered in a single en bloc package with a simple-majority vote, but Article III judges are excluded and still need individual votes. That is why the 100-plus figure covers the executive nominees, while the 22 judges must each be voted on one by one — and why Schmitt is pressing his colleagues to stay in Washington and work through them, evenings and weekends included.
What happens next is a test of whether the Senate will actually do that. Cloture motions ripen on Tuesday night for district court nominees Richard Bennett and Courtney Coker of Texas, Kyle Reardon of Alaska and Daniel Ballou of Kentucky, and the Judiciary Committee holds a hearing on Wednesday. Thune has pledged to keep the Senate in session into December to confirm as many as 25 judges before Democrats take the chamber on January 3. Whether the pace holds, and whether the senators standing in the way of their own states’ nominees relent, will decide how many of the 22 seats are filled for life and how many are left open.