First posted on Instagram
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent warned the Federal Reserve on Friday not to raise interest rates too far over inflation driven by an energy supply shock tied to the war with Iran, arguing the shock is already fading and the October inflation figures the Fed is reading are noisy. Bessent, speaking on CNBC's Squawk Box, said the central bank should look ahead rather than react to past price spikes, weeks before the Fed's December 8-9 meeting, where markets are pricing in a quarter-point increase.
The warning matters to households because the Fed's rate sets the cost of borrowing across the economy — mortgages, car loans and credit-card rates all move with it. A hike now would make borrowing more expensive for American families at the very moment the price pressure behind it is easing: gasoline has fallen below $4 a gallon, crude oil is down about $20 and diesel is down 10 percent, according to Bessent.
"I think the Fed should understand that this is an energy supply shock," Bessent said, adding that the underlying American economy is very strong. "I think that to hike too much into an energy supply shock when it's coming down, these are very noisy numbers," he said. "The Fed's supposed to look into the future, not look in the rearview mirror."
Bessent said he would not tell the Fed what to do, but that "they should have an open mind." He noted the Fed cut rates three times over the same period last year, and said reversing course dramatically because of an energy supply shock "isn't something that I would do if I were on the Fed. But I'm not on the Fed."
Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee pushed back on CNBC within the hour, saying price pressures have spread far beyond what oil can explain. "I respect the secretary and I am trying to figure out the same thing he is trying to figure out," Goolsbee said, but services inflation, "which is probably not coming from tariffs or oil, is one of the more troubling aspects" of recent reports. "The tariff inflation and oil price shock were supposed to have gone away by now and it hasn't," he said, adding that the Fed "has definitely got work to do to continue to reestablish its credibility" and that, asked whether inflation is on a path back to the Fed's 2 percent target, "my feeling right now is we are not."
The Fed raised its target range by a quarter point to 3.75 percent to 4 percent in September and held it steady in October. Fed Governor Christopher Waller said on Tuesday he planned to support a quarter-point increase at the December 8-9 meeting unless core consumer prices came in at 0.3 percent or more, and San Francisco Fed President Mary Daly has said a hike is likely given recent inflation data. CME FedWatch puts the chance of a quarter-point rise at the December meeting at about 89.4 percent, and some officials have discussed a larger-than-usual half-point increase.
Energy prices had climbed 20.4 percent year over year by September, and the consumer price index rose 0.4 percent in October. The average price of a gallon of gasoline is $3.87, down from $4.34 a month ago but still well above the $2.98 recorded on February 28, when the United States and Israel first struck Iran. The Labour Department was unable to collect data in October 2025 because of last year's government shutdown, so no year-over-year comparison is available for October 2026.
Central bankers have been burned before by tightening into an energy shock. In July 2008, the European Central Bank raised its key interest rate from 4 percent to 4.25 percent as oil prices surged, only to be forced to slash rates within months after Lehman Brothers collapsed that September and the global economy tipped into crisis.
The minutes of the Fed's October meeting are due on Wednesday, November 18, and the December 8-9 decision will show whether policymakers heed Bessent's warning or follow the market's expectation of another increase.