First posted on Instagram
Conservative activist Scott Presler said on Thursday he is auditing the voter rolls of a red, Republican state, county by county, and has found noncitizens who are both registered to vote and have a history of voting in federal elections. Thirty-eight minutes later he said he is submitting "a lot of voter fraud reports to the government website," adding: "Told you this is how I'm going to spend winter."
Only United States citizens may vote in federal elections, and registering to vote requires an affirmation of citizenship under penalty of perjury — so if Presler's findings are confirmed, the cases would fall to investigators and prosecutors to pursue under the law. His announcement has renewed calls from his supporters for a nationwide audit of voter rolls, and it lands as Congress weighs the SAVE America Act, which would require proof of citizenship to register to vote in federal elections.
What Presler did not say matters as much as what he did. He did not name the state — only "a red, Republican state" — he gave no number of noncitizens found, and he did not name the government website where he says he filed the reports. His own posts make no mention of the Trump administration. The claims themselves have not been independently verified: Presler has not released the names or records behind them, so no election office or news organisation has been able to check them.
The announcement follows months of similar work by Presler in Pennsylvania, where he and his Early Vote Action team hand-transcribed names from county non-juror lists — people excused from jury duty because they are not U.S. citizens — and cross-checked them against the state's voter rolls. From more than 20,700 non-citizen names obtained from those lists, roughly 27 percent flagged as matches on the Pennsylvania rolls, and in Philadelphia alone the team reported thousands of records and hundreds of potential matches. In September Presler wrote on X: "I will not stop until we have acquired the non-juror records for every county in Pennsylvania. We have found non-citizens in every single county — even red ones. Yes, many of them are registered voters." He has said the method found more than 5,000 Pennsylvania voters "flagged as matches," and his team said the data was turned over to the Department of Justice.
But the method itself has been challenged, and the checks so far have not confirmed what it flags. Votebeat and Spotlight PA scrutinised 13 potential noncitizen voters identified by this method in Chester County, Pennsylvania, and confirmed not one noncitizen voter: several of the people had since become naturalised citizens, and one apparent case turned out to be a county worker's data-entry error on the registration date. Pennsylvania election officials have said the non-juror lists contain limited identifying information and that name-only matches can produce false positives. And Presler has not released his results so they can be independently verified.
Presler's own record has also drawn scrutiny. In October, an investigation by The Bulwark found that three people outside Presler's family used his home address in Beaver County, Pennsylvania, to vote in the 2024 election. His Early Vote Action PAC acknowledged that others had used the home as their voter registration address, saying they lived there while working in Pennsylvania and have since moved on. Legal experts quoted in the coverage questioned whether those voters met the state's residency rules; no authority has ruled that Presler padded the rolls.
Noncitizen voting is not unknown to prosecutors: in September 2026 a federal grand jury in Minnesota indicted ten foreign nationals for making false claims of citizenship to vote or for voting as aliens, covering the November 2022 and November 2024 general elections and the August 2026 primary. What happens next with Presler's new reports depends on whether he names the state and releases the records — and on whether the officials who receive them confirm any of the cases.