A federal appeals court has handed New York a win and the Trump administration a setback — on procedure, not on the facts that started the fight. The Second Circuit on Friday threw out the Transportation Department's April decision to withhold $73.5 million in highway funding from New York, ruling that the department went beyond its legal authority when it tried to force the state to revoke commercial driver licenses.
The administration's case was built on an audit: federal investigators found New York had been routinely issuing commercial driver licenses to foreign drivers illegally, and when the state refused federal demands to revoke some of those licenses, the department held back the highway money. New York sued. The appeals court said the department's decision "runs afoul of fair notice principles, departs from the regulatory text, and underestimates the complexity of its supposedly 'common sense' requirement" — in plain words, the judges ruled on how the department acted, not on whether the licenses should ever have been issued.
The stakes were bigger than the $73.5 million already held: the department had also threatened to withhold an additional $147 million a year. New York had argued the loss of funding would put New Yorkers at risk. Spokespeople for Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy and for Governor Kathy Hochul did not immediately comment on Friday's ruling.
What this means for ordinary Americans is two things at once. New York's highway money now flows for the roads and bridges its drivers use every day — and the underlying question the audit raised, who is being licensed to drive heavy trucks on those roads and whether every one of those licenses was lawful, has not been answered by this ruling at all. The court's fight was over federal power and fair notice. The safety argument that started it — that a state was handing truck licenses to foreign drivers outside the law — remains the administration's case to make through the channels the court leaves open.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit:
https://white-curlew-963569.hostingersite.com
Never miss a story — Join our Telegram channel
Breaking U.S. political news, live as it happens — plus the stories the big outlets sit on.
Join ProfiloPolitics on Telegram