Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed said on Tuesday that Israel should uphold equal rights for all of its citizens and should not define its national identity through its Jewish heritage, telling The Atlantic's Jonathan Lemire at the magazine's Washington summit. "I believe that Israel ought to be a country that upholds equal rights for all of its citizens, does not identify itself with a culture or a faith, and that dignifies the rights of those citizens to live free under its laws," he said.
The remarks land as El-Sayed prepares to take his seat in the Senate on January 3 as the first Muslim American and Egyptian-American senator, after a campaign in which his record on Israel drew heavy scrutiny. He has now made his position plain before taking the oath: equal rights for all, no national identity built on a single faith or culture, and no commitment to a one-state or two-state framework — a question he said Israelis and Palestinians should decide themselves.
Lemire asked him what he would say to Jewish Americans who fear his criticism of Israel fuels antisemitism. "I'm sorry for your fear," El-Sayed said, drawing a line between safety and discomfort: "If what I'm saying is making you uncomfortable, you should be uncomfortable with injustice perpetrated on other people." He pointed to the war in Gaza, citing 70,000 people killed and homes, hospitals and universities destroyed. Rabbi Yaakov Menken of the Coalition for Jewish Values called the remarks "outrageous and hateful."
Former Speaker Nancy Pelosi had already rebuked the position on her "On Brand" podcast on October 30, calling it "wrong" and saying it "isn't a reflection of the Democrats in Congress." Critics have also asked why the argument stops at Israel: The Sherman Report noted Pakistan's constitution makes Islam the state religion and said it found no record of El-Sayed objecting. El-Sayed has used the word "ethnostate" himself — telling Mehdi Hasan in an earlier interview, "I just dispute the idea that you should have an ethnostate" — while insisting he does not dispute Israel's right to exist.
At the same summit he said the United States should end unconditional military aid to every country, naming "Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Pakistan, and Israel." El-Sayed, who called Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu a war criminal and accused Israel of genocide in Gaza, takes his seat in January, when his positions will face their first Senate tests.