First posted on Instagram
The Senate on Thursday rejected the latest effort to end President Donald Trump's war in Iran, voting 51-48 against a war powers resolution that would have directed the president to remove American forces from hostilities or seek Congress's approval to continue them. Senator John Fetterman of Pennsylvania was the only Democrat to vote against the measure, joining Republicans, while three Republicans — Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky — crossed the aisle to support it.
The vote was the Senate's first word on the war since voters stripped Republicans of both chambers of Congress on November 3 in elections widely tied to frustration with the conflict — and it leaves the war, which had cost $48.3 billion as of November 13, running without a congressional vote of approval, with the price still reaching households through fuel and the cost of living.
The measure was H.Con.Res. 93, a concurrent resolution approved by the House in September that directed the removal of United States Armed Forces from hostilities with Iran. As a concurrent resolution it would not have gone to the president's desk and carries no force of law — but it would have put both chambers on record against a war that began on February 28. Thursday's vote was the 15th such motion from Senate lawmakers this year, and the first vote on the war in either chamber since the midterms.
The crossovers have broken with their party on Iran war powers votes before. The one senator who changed sides was Thom Tillis of North Carolina, who voted for a similar effort in September — when the measure failed 49-50 — and voted no on Thursday. In June, the Senate went further, passing a war powers resolution 50-48 with a fourth Republican, Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, joining the three — the first time both chambers had agreed on such a rebuke of a sitting president. Fetterman, an ardent supporter of Israel, has sided with the Republican majority against the measures before.
Supporters of the resolution argue Congress must have a say in decisions involving military action and the president should not continue hostilities without congressional authorisation — the 1973 War Powers Resolution requires approval for conflicts lasting beyond 60 days, and the Iran campaign began February 28. Opponents argue the president needs flexibility as Commander in Chief to respond to national security threats, and the administration says there are no active hostilities to end because the United States and Iran agreed to a ceasefire on April 7.
The current Congress ends on January 3, 2027, and Democrats take both chambers that month, having pledged to use their majorities to investigate the administration's handling of the Iran war. Before then, Representative Thomas Massie says he will use Congress's war powers rules to force a House vote on his own resolution ending the conflict — H.Con.Res. 126, introduced November 10 — in the next few legislative days or around Christmas.