The Senate voted 48–36 on Friday to advance Daniel Lewis Ballou toward a lifetime seat on Kentucky's federal court, the Eastern District, moving President Trump's nominee one step from confirmation even as the state's own judicial conduct body pursues three misconduct charges against him.
A federal judgeship is for life, and the charges go to the core of the job — whether Ballou used his power as a state judge to punish a lawyer who posted a video he did not like. The Senate is pressing ahead before Democrats take control of Congress on January 3, 2027.
The charges: the Kentucky Judicial Conduct Commission opened formal proceedings on October 23, alleging Ballou improperly used his judicial authority to punish attorney Kerri Bartley over a social media video filmed in his McCreary County courtroom in August 2025, before proceedings began. Ballou summoned Bartley to appear in an unrelated criminal case; when she apologized, he interrupted her, asked where she went to law school and told her she "might want to look into a refund" if she had not learned better. Before she could respond, he had a bailiff hand her an order he had already drafted and signed, calling the video "childish, unprofessional, disrespectful, belligerent, immature, and extraordinarily arrogant" and barring her from carrying electronic devices at two courthouses. The commission says he decided the punishment before she appeared and gave her no chance to respond.
Ballou denies wrongdoing. In a response filed November 9, he argued his actions were within his authority to maintain order in a courtroom where filming and devices are banned, and called the matter "an improper selective prosecution." He has long been close to Sen. Rand Paul — he publicly supported Paul's 2010 Senate run, drawing a public reprimand from the same commission in 2011 for using his position as a judge to campaign for a political candidate.
The Senate Judiciary Committee sent Ballou through 12–10 on November 10, and Chairman Chuck Grassley called a state judge of nearly a quarter of a century hard to imagine as more qualified. A substantial majority of the American Bar Association rated Ballou "Qualified"; a minority rated him "Not Qualified." Sen. Dick Durbin called confirming a judge facing unresolved misconduct charges a dangerous example of rushing the bench.
The full confirmation vote is next. If confirmed, Ballou takes a lifetime seat on the Eastern District of Kentucky while the commission's case against him is still unresolved — no hearing date has been set.