The Trump administration asked a federal judge on Thursday to block the American Bar Association from deposing senior White House officials in its lawsuit challenging the White House's executive orders targeting major law firms, arguing that the association has not shown the "extraordinary circumstances" needed to question top officials and that the requested depositions raise privilege concerns. No ruling has been made yet on the request, which was filed with U.S. District Judge Amir Ali in Washington.
The depositions are the sharp end of a discovery fight over how the law-firm orders were made. If the association gets to question senior officials under oath, it can ask who ordered the punishments, who negotiated the deals that followed, and whether the two were connected. If the administration wins, the association must build its case from documents alone — and the White House has already argued that many of those documents are protected presidential communications. For lawyers and their clients, the question is whether firms can be punished for who they represent and what they say, and whether anyone at the top has to answer for it.
The administration's argument rests on the special protection courts give senior officials: a party that wants to depose them must show extraordinary circumstances, and the White House says the association has not done so. The filing also raises privilege concerns about questioning officials over their advice to the president. The association has not yet had its answer heard, and Judge Ali has not set a public timetable for deciding the request.
The case is American Bar Association v. Executive Office of the President, filed in June 2025 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. The association alleges the administration adopted an unlawful, coordinated policy of sanctioning law firms and their lawyers for engaging in speech the government does not like — a "law firm intimidation policy" aimed at firms over their legal work, their clients, their diversity initiatives and their perceived political associations. Four firms fought their individual executive orders in court and won: Perkins Coie, Jenner & Block, WilmerHale and Susman Godfrey, whose orders were permanently blocked by four different judges for violating the Constitution. Nine other firms took a different route, striking deals with the administration that pledged nearly $1 billion in free legal work for causes the president supports. Judge Ali denied the government's motion to dismiss the association's suit earlier this year, and the case moved into discovery.
The deposition fight follows a records order from the same judge three days earlier. On Monday, November 16, Judge Ali issued a 26-page memorandum opinion and order granting in part and denying in part the association's motion to compel the Executive Office of the President to answer 16 document requests. Ali ordered the administration to produce the agreements it struck with the nine firms and its communications with them from January 20 to June 30, 2025, plus its communications from January 20 to April 30, 2025 with the five firms it targeted with punitive orders that did not settle — Covington & Burling, Jenner & Block, Perkins Coie, Susman Godfrey and WilmerHale. He also ordered drafts of the executive orders, including redlines and the messages that sent them, and memoranda on the orders. "The requested communications are 'directly relevant' to whether the government issued retaliatory sanction threats that would have discouraged ABA members from engaging in activity protected by the First Amendment," the judge said. He granted narrowed versions of five requests and denied the other 11, some only for now, and noted that some — even many — of the records may turn out to be privileged. The parties must agree on search terms and propose a schedule by December 4, and the government has until December 28 to obtain documents from the firms and hand them over.
The administration has resisted this discovery at every step. When the association asked for communications involving Boris Epshteyn, the president's personal senior counsel, and Steve Bannon, the Justice Department subpoenaed the law firms themselves for their Epshteyn communications — conceding the material was relevant — and then tried to have Susman Godfrey, the association's own counsel, disqualified as a witness. Judge Ali denied that motion, finding the government could not name a single Susman lawyer who would actually have to testify. When Ali ordered the government to say who drafted the executive orders, the administration invoked presidential privilege over the names themselves. The White House has said it plans to challenge the November 16 records order, and it may ask Ali to pause the order while it appeals.
What happens next is in Judge Ali's hands: a ruling on whether senior White House officials can be deposed, and in parallel, the December 4 meeting where the two sides must agree on search terms for the records the judge has already ordered produced. The depositions, if allowed, would be the first time administration officials answer under oath about the orders and the deals. If blocked, the association's case will rest on the paper trail alone.