The Board of Peace, the body created by the United States to oversee President Donald Trump's Gaza ceasefire, delivered a bleak report to the United Nations Security Council on Tuesday, warning that the year-old truce could collapse if Israel and Hamas do not move to full implementation of the deal. “The distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground nonetheless remains the principal risk to the process,” the report says.
Why it matters is written on the ground in Gaza, where some two million people live in dire conditions and, in the board's words, face “another winter in tents and rubble.” As many as 1,650 people have been reported killed in Gaza since the ceasefire took effect, according to Gaza health authorities. It matters for America because this is Washington's deal: the board was created at Trump's behest under his 20-point peace plan, he chairs it himself, and its collapse would take the whole structure down with it — “no road map to return to, no administration to deploy and no enabling environment to rebuild.”
The report's own verdict is blunt. “A ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely,” it says. It blames restrictions imposed by Israel on the entry of supplies and equipment, compounded by funding shortfalls, for hampering relief work, and demands immediate “scaled-up entry of shelter and winterization materials” plus approvals for pumps, generators and heavy machinery. The board, endorsed by the Security Council when it backed the plan last year, is run day to day by director-general Nickolay Mladenov, a former UN Mideast envoy, whose first report in May already said the truce had stalled over disarming Hamas.

The contrast with what was promised is the heart of the report. The deal was meant to deliver an Israeli troop withdrawal, Hamas disarmed, an international stabilization force, a technocratic Palestinian administration to run Gaza in the interim, and reconstruction at scale. Instead, the board says, the administration it created has still not been allowed by Israel to take up its job: “The absence of decisions by the government of Israel on the necessary conditions and arrangements for the training, deployment and return of civilian police to Gaza continues to impede full implementation of the Comprehensive Plan.” Israel is called on to decide “without delay” — and those missing approvals are holding up the stabilization force on which withdrawal, disarmament and rebuilding all depend.
Both sides are named in the failure: the report points to continued Israeli strikes in Gaza and continued Hamas military activity. Hamas agreed to the board's disarmament plan on July 30 after months of talks, but progress has stalled, with Israel arguing the plan will not make Hamas actually surrender all its weapons. Israel says it has moved to address the shelter crisis, though some 70,000 tents were reportedly flooded by winter rains earlier this month. From Israel's own camp, Ron Dermer, a former top aide to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, said this week: “I say give a shot to this Board of Peace,” adding that Israel would need to allow steps such as tax revenues, training a new police force and a technocratic government.
What happens next rests on decisions the report says can no longer wait. The board has appealed to the Security Council to put its full weight behind the deal it endorsed, insisting that “neither party may treat the other's delay as license for its own inaction,” and that the end result “must lead to the credible pathway to Palestinian self-determination and statehood.” Winter is arriving in Gaza now, the police and administration decisions are still unmade in Jerusalem, and the ceasefire's own overseer has put in writing that a truce delivering nothing visible will not hold.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here