The Justice Department offered $500,000 each to five plaintiffs in a class action over IRS data stolen by a government contractor — $2.5 million in total, about 250 times what the law called for on the allegations — ProPublica reported on November 19.
The size of the offer is what makes the story matter, and so is who got it. Among the five recipients were Shelby Lowman, the longtime golf pro at Trump National Golf Club Hudson Valley, and Safe Harbor International, a company whose investors include Donald Wilson, whose firm said it invested $100 million in Trump Media. Multiple officials told ProPublica that cases like this rarely reach that size. For households watching the Justice Department from the outside, the question is a simple one: why did a routine data-breach claim, filed by people with ties to the president's businesses, draw an offer worth a quarter of a thousand times the statute's figure — and why was it made the way it was?
The case is Safe Harbor International LLC v. Booz Allen Hamilton, the Internal Revenue Service and the U.S. Department of the Treasury, brought in Maryland federal court in 2025. The plaintiffs claim the IRS and the government contractor Booz Allen failed to protect confidential tax records from being leaked. Between 2018 and 2020, Booz Allen contractor Charles Littlejohn stole private IRS data on high-income individuals and corporate entities and leaked it to news outlets, including ProPublica and The New York Times. Littlejohn pleaded guilty and was sentenced to five years in prison.
The Justice Department initially sought to have the lawsuit thrown out. Then, in August, it reversed course. Rather than continuing to contest the claims, two Trump-appointed officials — civil division head Brett Shumate and tax litigation branch deputy assistant attorney general Joshua Wu — stepped in to extend the settlement offer. ProPublica reported that the career DOJ trial attorney assigned to the case did not sign off on the settlement proposal, as is standard practice, and that IRS Office of Chief Counsel attorneys were not consulted about the settlement terms. The offer came before any final court decision and gave up the department's right to appeal.
ProPublica wrote that it was unclear whether Trump knows Lowman personally. The Trump Organization denied involvement in the lawsuit. The Justice Department and the IRS declined to comment, and the White House said the department seeks efficient case resolution. No judge has yet ruled on whether the class action can proceed, and nothing in the reporting establishes wrongdoing by any recipient — the offer itself, and the way it was made, is what ProPublica documented.
What happens next is in the court's hands: the class action has not been decided, and the offer's unusual size and path — political appointees signing, career lawyers bypassed, IRS counsel left out — are now part of the public record for the judge and for Congress to weigh.