It turns out, elections have consequences. Canarsie, Brooklyn, is finding that out the hard way: Mayor Zohran Mamdani's administration is building a 200-bed, all-male homeless shelter at 945 East 108th Street — one block from the Science and Medicine Middle School 366 — and on Monday night the neighborhood, a quiet stretch of mostly Black homeowners, came out into the street to say nobody ever asked them.
The shelter, to be run by the nonprofit Midway Living, is not a rumour. A Department of Homeless Services letter dated October 5 confirmed it to Council Member Mercedes Narcisse: 200 beds for single men, scheduled to open in 2028. A Department of Social Services spokesperson says the site is part of a city plan to build 12 shelters across the boroughs over four years, three of them in Brooklyn. What residents say they cannot forgive is how they learned of it. A year ago, some 150 of them rallied and were assured the building would not become a shelter; Narcisse says she was told last year there was no shelter plan at all. "You want to put it next to a school!" she told the crowd. "A middle school, for God's sake!"
The signs said it plainly — "NO SHELTERS NEAR SCHOOLS" and "DEVELOPERS GOT PAID, RESIDENTS GET NO SAY" — and the chant was "No shelter! Near schools!" One mother spoke of her daughter coming out of that school; another resident told how her 86-year-old father, still working and paying property taxes, has already been robbed twice without a shelter on the block, and asked what happens when there is one. Parents say children walk alone to after-school activities past the site. The crowd's demand was simple: the mayor should come to a community meeting on Thursday and answer for the decision in person.
The fight has already travelled far beyond Canarsie. A post putting the neighborhood's case in two sentences — "Mayor Mamdani is building a 200 bed all-male homeless shelter right near a black school. Turns out, elections have consequences." — has been viewed well over 100,000 times, and it names the bargain the protesters feel they were handed: they voted, the city decided, and the first they heard of it was a letter.
For the families on those blocks the question is not whether homeless men deserve shelter — it is whether a city that campaigns on listening gets to place 200 beds beside a middle school without ever facing the parents whose children walk past it. On Monday night, Canarsie started its answer.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit:
https://white-curlew-963569.hostingersite.com
Never miss a story — Join our Telegram channel
Breaking U.S. political news, live as it happens — plus the stories the big outlets sit on.
Join ProfiloPolitics on Telegram