The Wall Street Journal reported on Saturday that President Trump was close to firing Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick earlier this year, after Lutnick admitted in congressional testimony that he visited Jeffrey Epstein's private island. Then Lutnick gave $25 million to Trump's presidential library, and — according to the Journal, citing unnamed people familiar with the matter — Trump stopped talking about replacing him.
Why it matters: a secretary's survival laid beside a $25 million gift to the president's own library is a claim about how power works, and it stands or falls on sourcing. The Journal itself reports a sequence, not a deal: it does not report that the money was offered or accepted in exchange for the job, and neither man has said so.
What is on the record is Lutnick's own voice, twice. In October 2025 he described touring Epstein's New York home in 2005 and deciding with his wife he would "never be in the room with that disgusting person ever again." On February 10, under questioning from Senator Chris Van Hollen, he said of the island: "I did have lunch with him as I was on a boat going across on a family vacation. My wife was with me, as were my four children and nannies. We had lunch on the island. That is true for an hour." Van Hollen answered in the same hearing that there is "not an indication that you yourself engaged in any wrongdoing with Jeffrey Epstein" — the charge was that Lutnick misled the country about cutting off contact.
Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick confirms the island lunch under Senate questioning, February 10 — C-SPAN
The $25 million itself is not new, and it arrived with a different explanation. It was first reported in "Regime Change," by New York Times reporters Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan, as a gift meant to ease Trump's anger over scrutiny of Lutnick's sons, who took over his firm, Cantor Fitzgerald. What the Journal adds is the timing, and the portrait around it: a secretary who meets Trump alone at the White House after staff have gone home, takes directives other advisers never hear, and has also survived the Nvidia controversy — the paper calls him "the ultimate survivor."
Lutnick is still in the Cabinet, and the Journal's question is still exactly that — a question. A named source, a document, or an answer on the record from either man would settle it. Until one exists, readers are holding a timeline built by unnamed sources — and a timeline is not a transaction.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here