Democrats, having won Congress, are reviving the push for 18-year term limits on Supreme Court justices — and the sharpest proposal on the table would force out three justices at once. Maryland Rep. Johnny Olszewski's constitutional amendment, the Reform of Bench Eligibility (ROBE) Act, filed on May 4, would cap a justice's service at 18 years and apply to the current Court, ending the service of Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Chief Justice John Roberts, all of whom have served longer than that.
The stakes are the shape of American law for a generation. Justices serve for life under the Constitution's promise of office 'during good Behaviour,' so a president's picks can steer the Court for decades after he leaves office. Thomas has sat since 1991 — 35 years — while Roberts joined in 2005 and Alito in 2006, and the three anchor the Court's 6–3 conservative majority. Term limits would make appointments regular and predictable: under the Democratic plans, every president would get two picks per four-year term, instead of vacancies arriving by chance.
Both measures sat shelved while Republicans ran Congress. Olszewski filed his amendment in May, days after the Court's ruling gutting the Voting Rights Act, and chose the amendment route because he does not trust the Court to uphold a statute limiting its own power. His measure includes provisions for a fair and orderly transition, rather than an overnight purge. The other vehicle is Rep. Hank Johnson's TERM Act, a regular law reintroduced on May 21, 2025: 18 years of active service, then senior status — keeping the title, salary and office for life — with a new justice appointed every two years, the longest-serving justice stepping aside first, beginning with Thomas.
Neither route is close to law. The amendment needs two-thirds of both chambers and ratification by 38 states, which no Democratic majority can deliver alone, and the statute route faces the Senate's 60-vote wall and then a constitutional fight over whether Congress can shorten a life appointment by law. Critics call the push a partisan answer to a 6–3 Court; supporters say regular turnover would lower the stakes of every vacancy. Incoming Speaker Hakeem Jeffries has made clear the Court is on his mind for the new Congress, which is seated on January 3 — so the fight over the three longest-serving conservatives is an agenda fight for January, not a done deal.