The full U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit ruled 9-8 on Friday that the House unconstitutionally passed the $1.7 trillion Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2023, because 226 members voted by proxy and the Constitution's Quorum Clause counts only members physically present. The ruling upholds an injunction blocking the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act — the one piece of the bill Texas challenged — against Texas, and the case now heads for the Supreme Court.
The decision casts doubt on one of the largest spending bills ever passed — every law in the 2023 omnibus rode on the same proxy vote — though the court limited its order to the pregnant-workers provision in Texas. If the Supreme Court agrees, challengers could target other parts of the bill.
Judge Cory Wilson, writing for the majority, said the Quorum Clause's "text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application all indicate that Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes." "'Proxy presence' does not count," he wrote. "The Quorum Clause's constraints on congressional power cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat."
Then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi put the proxy rule in place in May 2020 as a COVID emergency measure. The House used it to pass the spending package 225-201 in December 2022, with 226 members voting by proxy, before Republicans scrapped the rule after taking the House. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued, and U.S. District Judge James "Wes" Hendrix ruled for Texas in 2024. A three-judge panel had sided with Congress, but that ruling was vacated when the full court reheard the case. The case is State of Texas v. Blanche, No. 24-10386.
Judge James Graves, in dissent, called the ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid," saying the majority read a physical-presence requirement into the clause that is not there and gave "no explanation" for limiting relief to "one small sliver of the multi-trillion dollar bill." The decision is certain to be appealed to the Supreme Court, Bloomberg Law reported — and a Democrat has just won the Texas attorney general race, so Republicans will no longer control the office that brought the challenge from January.