First posted on Instagram
Chinese officials barred Bloomberg reporter Annmarie Hordern from the first-ever meeting of Presidents Donald Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen on Thursday, after she shouted a question at Trump during his earlier one-on-one with Xi — asking whether former Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang had been "disloyal to the United States." The White House pressed for Hordern to be readmitted to the trilateral session. Beijing refused, and she missed the opening of the most closely watched meeting of the week.
The exclusion decides what Americans get to see of their own president's diplomacy. Hordern was part of the travelling White House press pool — the small group of reporters who witness the opening moments of presidential meetings and report them back. When a host government can remove a pool reporter for asking an unwelcome question, the record of what was said in the room narrows to what the hosts choose to release.
The question came as Trump sat across a long table from Xi at Kylin Villa, the state-owned lakeside resort outside Shenzhen. "President Trump, has Jensen Huang been disloyal to the United States?" Hordern called out. Trump did not answer. Xi looked toward the reporters, then away, as a security guard moved in and blocked a camera that had been recording the exchange, the New York Times reported. A second reporter started to ask a question and was shushed by Chinese officials, according to the White House pool report.
The pool report carried Beijing's warning to the travelling press. "The Chinese have passed along a message that yelling questions is considered extremely rude and we will be pulled from the room if we do so," it said. A White House official, speaking on condition of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the issue, said the administration sought Hordern's reinstatement but Chinese officials insisted she be excluded from the trilateral meeting.
The question was about a scandal that has followed Trump to Shenzhen. Huang resigned last week as Nvidia's chief executive after admitting an extramarital affair with a woman U.S. officials say was recruited by Chinese intelligence — an allegation Beijing denies. The woman, Alice Huang, is not related to Jensen Huang. Trump has since suggested on Truth Social that Apple's Tim Cook should take Huang's place at Nvidia. Huang has agreed to testify before the Senate Banking Committee next month, and he and Nvidia general counsel Tim Teter are due before three House committees on December 1.
The meeting Hordern was kept out of was the first time the leaders of the United States, China and Russia have ever sat down together. It ran about 90 minutes, with nuclear arms cuts, Iran, Ukraine and trade on the agenda, and produced a joint statement declaring that a nuclear war "cannot be won and must never be fought." Hordern, Bloomberg's chief political correspondent, had been in the pool for the bilateral session that preceded it.
What happens next is a test of how far the White House will push back. No formal protest had been lodged by Thursday evening, and it is not yet clear whether Hordern will be restored to the pool for the rest of Trump's Asia trip — or whether the exclusion stands as the precedent for how American reporters are treated when their questions embarrass a host.