First posted on Instagram
Senator John Cornyn of Texas is blocking one of President Donald Trump's final judicial nominees, withholding his approval for T. Elliot Gaiser to serve as a federal judge in Dallas. Cornyn declined to return the Senate Judiciary Committee's "blue slip" for Gaiser, the form through which home-state senators signal support for a district-court nominee, keeping Gaiser off the committee's hearing agenda on Wednesday, November 18, and effectively stalling the nomination.
Time is almost up: Republicans are racing to confirm as many of Trump's judges as possible before Democrats take control of the Senate on January 3, when unconfirmed nominations die. Gaiser, 37, leads the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel; Trump announced his selection on November 9 and sent the nomination to the Senate on November 16.
Cornyn said Gaiser should not get a lifetime appointment on the Texas bench. "He's not from Texas," Cornyn told Reuters. "He has no trial experience, and the White House was trying to jam him down our throat without adequate vetting for a lifetime job." Gaiser previously served as Ohio's solicitor general and clerked for Judge Edith Jones on the Fifth Circuit, but has few apparent ties to Texas. Cornyn has instead recommended former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey of Texas for the seat.
The blue slip is a long-standing Judiciary Committee custom, not a constitutional requirement: district-court nominees generally do not advance to a confirmation hearing without signed blue slips from both home-state senators, giving a single senator an effective veto over a nominee in their state. Cornyn is serving his final months after losing the Republican primary to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who was backed by Trump, and he has told the Associated Press he does not plan to return the blue slip.
Cornyn is not the only Republican senator pushing back on the White House's last-minute picks. Outgoing Senator Alan Armstrong has also blocked a nominee, and the White House replaced its Eighth Circuit pick after two Arkansas senators objected. A White House official told the Associated Press the administration still expects all of Trump's judicial nominees to be confirmed by the end of the year.
What happens next: Gaiser's nomination stays stalled unless Cornyn relents or the White House withdraws it and names a different pick — and with the Senate's remaining session days now counted in the teens, either path is running short on time.