First posted on Instagram
A crowd at the Bartow City Commission meeting in Florida drowned out an imam's opening prayer on Monday night, reciting the Lord's Prayer aloud and chanting "Christ is King" as Imam Sajid R. Bhuiya of the Masjid Al Nur Mosque stood at the podium trying to give the invocation. For nearly ten minutes, Bhuiya stood at the podium attempting to say a prayer while protesters yelled over him, and police eventually escorted protesters out of the meeting room. No one was arrested.
The disruption matters because it was aimed at a prayer the city itself had put on its agenda — and because it split the room over whether any religion belongs at the opening of a public meeting. Bhuiya had been listed as the invocation speaker for the commission's regular meeting on Monday, November 16, at City Hall. When commissioners introduced him, members of the crowd immediately began reciting the Lord's Prayer aloud before he could speak, and shouted "USA, USA, USA," "This is a Christian nation," and ethnic epithets, according to the USA Today Network, which covered the meeting. Mayor Tanya Tucker warned the crowd they would be asked to leave, and Bhuiya began about eight minutes later and finished his prayer, calling for dignity, respect and kindness across religious differences.
Commissioner Trish Pfeiffer told the meeting that commissioners had received 214 emails about the invocation. "We govern a city of people, not a congregation of faith," she said — and then led the room in the Lord's Prayer herself. City Attorney Sean Parker took responsibility for the invitation, explaining that he had suggested reaching out to Bartow's mosque, alongside a local Hindu temple, to broaden religious representation at commission openings. Vice Mayor Laura Simpson said the city had not invited the invocation — the date was open when the mosque asked — and that if one religion were excluded, the city risked losing the opening prayer for all religions, including Christianity.
The anger had been building before the meeting: the announcement that Bhuiya would give the invocation drew angry comments on the city's public Facebook page on November 13 and 14, with some commenters urging people to show up and pray over the imam. More than 15 residents spoke during a public comment session lasting over an hour, most objecting to an Islamic prayer opening a city meeting, while others defended religious freedom. A federal appeals court upheld the City of Lakeland's invocation policy in 2013, opening the invocation to every religious congregation with an established presence in the area. What happens next is the question the commission now faces: whether to keep opening its meetings with prayer from any faith that asks, or to end the practice altogether.