The Justice Department fired back on Thursday at Rep. Robert Garcia, the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee, calling his letter accusing Attorney General Todd Blanche of withholding Epstein files “another shameful attempt to confuse and lie to the American public.” Garcia wrote to Blanche on Wednesday charging that the department has released only 3.5 million of the 6 million Epstein-related pages it has acknowledged holding, and has not explained what happened to the rest.
At stake is what Congress and the public get to see of the Epstein files — and who decides. Garcia says Democrats will subpoena Blanche in January, when they take control of the House, if the department does not turn over the remaining pages. The department says it has already complied with the law and offered lawmakers access to the unredacted files.
“The Department of Justice has complied with the EFTA [and] has released the responsive documents,” the department wrote on X, referring to the Epstein Files Transparency Act. “AG Blanche has answered Congress’ questions about Epstein and Maxwell at length and offered to meet with members, providing them with the ability to view unredacted files.”
Garcia’s letter took the opposite view. “DOJ’s response has been shockingly inadequate and unacceptable,” he wrote, accusing the administration of a broader effort to conceal information related to Epstein. “You have refused to cooperate with our investigation or to fulfill your legal responsibilities to be transparent with the Committee and the American people,” he told Blanche.
The numbers are the heart of the dispute. The act ordered the department to release its Epstein records, and on January 30 it said it had published 3.5 million responsive pages. Garcia and Oversight Democrats say that is only about half of the roughly 6 million pages collected, and that the rest is being withheld unlawfully. The department says the unreleased pages are duplicates, privileged, or part of ongoing investigations.
The department’s post added that Democrats “didn’t care about Epstein for years” while they oversaw the investigations under Maureen Comey and Merrick Garland, and noted that Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell were prosecuted only under President Trump. Garcia has given the department until December 2 to answer his letter; if it does not, he says Democrats will use their new House majority to compel Blanche’s testimony.