First posted on Instagram
Dr. Mehmet Oz, the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, warned that Democratic proposals aimed at making health care and other essential services more affordable could cost as much as $212 trillion, saying the spending would "crush the system" and devastate the programmes Americans rely on — and that purging fraud from Medicaid has to come first.
The warning lands as Democrats, fresh from winning both chambers of Congress in the November 3 midterm elections, press a 100-day agenda to reverse Medicaid cuts, restore food assistance funding and extend Affordable Care Act tax credits — promises that will decide what millions of households pay for coverage next year and whether the programmes themselves survive the bill. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries set out the agenda in a manifesto published November 4, and the Congressional Budget Office has priced reversing the Medicaid cuts and extending the subsidies alone at $2 trillion over a decade.
The $212 trillion figure is the top end of a tally by Rachel Greszler, a senior research fellow at Advancing American Freedom, of the Democrats' full wish list — $71 trillion to $212 trillion in new spending over the next decade, or between $500,000 and $1.6 million for every household in the country, as reported by Fox News. Universal health care alone accounts for $40 trillion to $70 trillion of it, according to the tally. In an earlier appearance on the same programme, Fox News' America Reports, Oz put his own number on Medicare for All — $47 trillion over a decade, citing a Council of Economic Advisers estimate — and warned that even the most aggressive Democratic tax proposals would raise only about half of what the plan requires, leaving a roughly $25 trillion funding gap. "If you CRUSH the system, you will devastate the systems we have and leave NOTHING in their place!" Oz said in the clip.
Democrats and supporters of broader affordability reforms argue the changes are necessary to reduce costs, expand access to essential services and ease the financial pressure on ordinary Americans. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that making the expanded Affordable Care Act credits permanent would add roughly $350 billion to federal deficits between 2026 and 2035 — and help about 3.8 million more Americans get coverage in 2035 — while the health care cuts in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act would reduce federal Medicaid spending by about $1.2 trillion over the same period at the cost of cutting enrollment by about 13 million. The $212 trillion figure itself is a disputed estimate, not an established government spending total.
Oz's alternative is the fraud purge. On November 16 his agency issued its CRUSH proposed rule — Comprehensive Regulations to Uncover Suspicious Healthcare — aimed at saving taxpayers nearly $90 billion over ten years by targeting fraud across Medicare, Medicaid, the Children's Health Insurance Program and the Marketplace. The agency says programme integrity savings rose 59 percent, from $26.3 billion in fiscal 2024 to a record $41.9 billion in fiscal 2025, and Oz has put total fraud across the programmes at about $100 billion a year. But the purge itself is contested: on November 17, Senators Alex Padilla, Adam Schiff and Ron Wyden led colleagues in demanding answers from Oz, accusing his agency of withholding billions of dollars from Democratic-led states while dismantling the federal infrastructure built to detect and prevent fraud. Oz and Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. say the rule gives the agency stronger tools to block fraudulent payments, remove dishonest providers and protect the Americans who rely on the programmes.
The CRUSH rule is open for public comment until January 19, 2027. The wider affordability fight now moves to the new Congress, seated in January, where the Democratic majorities will press their 100-day agenda against a president who has vowed to veto what he calls insane Democratic bills until they negotiate — and where the question of who pays for cheaper health care will be settled in the open.