Wednesday, November 18, 2026 (two days ago) — Senator Dick Durbin grilled President Trump's court pick James Sullivan at his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing on Wednesday, calling Sullivan's nomination for a lifetime federal judgeship a "consolation prize" for losing his Texas Supreme Court election. Durbin, the committee's ranking Democrat, used his opening statement to criticise Senate Republicans for fast-tracking Trump's judicial nominees in the lame-duck session before Democrats take the Senate majority in January.
"We have another state Supreme Court Justice before us today, James Sullivan, nominated to the Western District of Texas," Durbin said. "This is an amazing political story. Two weeks ago, Justice Sullivan lost his bid to be reelected to the Texas Supreme Court. The very next day, the Administration submitted his Questionnaire, which had obviously been prepared in advance. It appears that a federal district court appointment for life is the consolation prize if you lose an election for the Texas Supreme Court."
Why it matters: the hearing was the first time Sullivan faced senators since Trump nominated him, and Durbin's attack frames the nomination as a reward for a losing candidate rather than a merit pick. Sullivan lost his Texas Supreme Court re-election bid on November 3, and his questionnaire reached the committee the next day, November 4. Durbin argued that committee norms generally allow at least 28 days between a nominee's questionnaire and a hearing, and he said Republicans were breaking those norms to install Trump's picks before Democrats take control on January 3.
What happens next: the committee must vote on Sullivan's nomination before it can go to the full Senate, and Democrats take the majority on January 3. Sullivan has not responded to Durbin's remarks, and the committee has not said when it will vote.
— What follows is the story as first written · the update is above —
President Donald Trump on Tuesday formally named three more nominees for federal judgeships, announcing the picks on Truth Social as the Republican-controlled Senate races to confirm his nominees before Democrats take control of the chamber in January.
Trump said he was nominating Justice Department official T. Elliot Gaiser to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Texas Supreme Court Justice James Sullivan to the United States District Court for the Western District of Texas, and William Grayson Lambert to the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina, Bloomberg Law reported.
Gaiser has served in the Justice Department and clerked for Justice Samuel Alito, Judge Neomi Rao of the D.C. Circuit and Judge Edith Jones of the Fifth Circuit. Sullivan was appointed to the Texas Supreme Court in 2025 by Governor Greg Abbott. Lambert is a partner in the Columbia, South Carolina, office of Nelson Mullins.
The announcements came after the paperwork for all three nominees had already been sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee. The Senate had already received questionnaire materials for Gaiser and Sullivan, and the paperwork for Lambert had been sent to the committee on November 4.
The three join a confirmation pile-up. There are 161 nominations awaiting Senate action, including 51 judicial nominations. Republicans have already confirmed 25 district and circuit court judges this year, with 17 more approved by the Judiciary Committee and waiting for a floor vote.
The Senate Judiciary Committee met on Tuesday, holding a nominations hearing and voting on six nominees. The hearing included district court nominees as the committee moved through its agenda.