Sixteen Ecuadorian fishermen have sued the United States government in federal court in Pittsburgh, saying American drones sank their fishing boat off the Galápagos Islands on March 17, then detained the survivors at gunpoint and took them to El Salvador — hours after Ecuador's own navy had inspected the vessel and cleared it of any wrongdoing. The suit, filed on Monday, November 16, seeks $5 million in damages and a court order stopping U.S. lethal strikes on boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific.
The case matters because it is the first time survivors of one of the administration's boat strikes have put their account before an American judge. The fishermen say they lost the only boat they had and with it their livelihoods — their captain told Reuters, "We filed the lawsuit because the boat was all we had. Nobody in Ecuador is helping us." For the administration, the suit tests the legal foundation of a campaign that, by the fishermen's count in the complaint, has carried out 71 strikes and killed at least 235 people since September 2025.
"These premeditated and intentional attacks against defenseless people lack any plausible legal justification," the fishermen said in the 17-page complaint, filed as Flores Franco v. United States, No. 2:26-cv-02459, in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania. The complaint says that on March 17, 2026, the United States "authorized and launched an attack, including by armed drones," against the La Negra Francisca Duarte II, carrying 16 fishermen in the Pacific off Ecuador, and that the attack took place "despite the fact that the government of Ecuador, after a three-hour inspection, had just cleared the ship and its crew of any illicit activity."
According to the complaint, two armed drones launched from a U.S.-operated vessel struck the boat as it headed home to the port of Manta after two weeks of fishing, about 385 nautical miles out. The vessel was engulfed in flames and destroyed, and two crew members — Jordy Alexander Flores Lucas and Leonel Alberto Pilay Barahona — suffered serious burns. The survivors escaped in emergency boats, the complaint says, and were then held by the United States for around 24 hours, their hands tied and hoods placed on their heads, with little water and no food, before being shipped by sea to El Salvador, where they were held for days in what the complaint calls deplorable conditions. The suit brings claims of assault, battery, false imprisonment and intentional infliction of emotional distress under admiralty and maritime law, and names 18 plaintiffs, including the boat's owner. The fishermen are represented by Pittsburgh attorney Daniel Kovalik and Ecuadorian lawyer Jorge Chiriboga Dávalos.
The U.S. government has denied involvement in this specific attack. The Pentagon said it does not comment on pending litigation, and U.S. Southern Command previously denied involvement in the March 17 incident; the Defense Department and Coast Guard have said they took no part in any of the three unexplained attacks on Ecuadorian fishing boats this year. White House spokeswoman Anna Kelly said in a statement that all boat strikes "have been against designated narcoterrorists bringing deadly poison to our shores." The administration has acknowledged dozens of lethal strikes on vessels it calls drug traffickers, but the La Negra Francisca Duarte II is not among the acknowledged incidents. The Washington Post previously reported that the mystery attacks on Ecuadorian boats were part of a presidentially approved CIA covert action programme, and the fishermen's lawyers say they will ask the court to investigate whether the CIA was involved.
The case was assigned to Judge Marilyn J. Horan the day after it was filed. Kovalik said he sued in Pittsburgh because of the court's maritime-law expertise in western Pennsylvania, which includes the three rivers through the city and a port on Lake Erie. The suit is the second against the Trump administration over the boat-strike campaign; Kovalik previously filed a case over a strike that presumably killed a Colombian fisherman. What happens next is the government's answer to the complaint, and whether a judge agrees to examine the campaign's legal basis — including the fishermen's argument that there is no armed conflict that could justify military force against the boats, and that the strikes were carried out without congressional authorisation.