First posted on Instagram
Elon Musk has accused South Africa of being "super racist" against white and Asian people, posting on X on Tuesday that "South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians" — hours after President Cyril Ramaphosa told the Pretoria-born billionaire he owed the country that raised and educated him and should give something back. Starlink, Musk's satellite internet service, still has no licence to operate in South Africa, blocked by a law requiring telecommunications licence holders to hand at least 30 per cent of their local business to historically disadvantaged groups, and the regulator has now formally ordered SpaceX to stop providing the service in the country.
The row matters beyond the two men because it is keeping fast internet out of reach for the South Africans who need it most. Starlink has offered to connect 5,000 mostly rural schools to high-speed satellite broadband free of charge, in a package it values at R500 million that would reach about 2.4 million learners a year — but the offer has sat untouched for more than a year while the licensing dispute drags on, and South Africans who bought Starlink kits through neighbouring countries have already been cut off once. For foreign investors, the standoff is a test of whether South Africa's empowerment rules are a price of doing business or a barrier that keeps global technology out.
Ramaphosa made his appeal in an interview with ABC News chief Washington correspondent Jonathan Karl at the Semafor "Silicon Valley & The World" event in California on Monday, November 16, where he is leading a delegation of nearly 300 people seeking artificial intelligence investment. "I have met Elon Musk in the past, and I've been awed by his brilliance, but I would also like to chat to him about remembering his country," Ramaphosa said. He argued that Musk's schooling in South Africa helped make him, saying: "When the apartheid government spent R12 on his education, it spent R1 on my education." Ramaphosa said a meeting with Musk had been discussed during the trip but their schedules did not line up, and he insisted that any company wanting to operate in South Africa must follow its laws: "When you want to come and operate here, you've got to subscribe to the policies of the country."
First posted on Instagram
Musk answered within hours, replying on X to a post carrying a clip of Ramaphosa's interview: "South Africa is now super racist against Whites and Asians." The post is the sharpest turn yet in a feud Musk has been escalating for months. Last week he demanded international sanctions unless South Africa repeals what he calls "super racist Apartheid 2.0 laws," writing: "If South Africa doesn't change its super racist Apartheid 2.0 laws, the country must be sanctioned." He has repeatedly called the ownership rules "openly racist ownership laws" and claimed Starlink is blocked "simply because I am not Black," and in April he wrote that South Africa had passed 142 laws "forcing discrimination against anyone who is not black."
At the centre of the dispute is the Electronic Communications Act, which requires holders of individual telecommunications licences to have at least 30 per cent ownership by historically disadvantaged groups — Black people, women, young people and people with disabilities. SpaceX, which owns Starlink, does not sell local stakes in its operations in any market, and Musk has refused to give up a share of a South African business. The South African government maintains that the rules are not about race but about redress: Black Economic Empowerment policies are designed to address the lasting economic inequalities created by apartheid and expand opportunities for historically disadvantaged communities. The presidency's spokesman, Vincent Magwenya, has dismissed Musk's claims as "repeated lies," and the foreign ministry has said Starlink is welcome to operate in South Africa provided it complies with local laws.
The dispute has now moved from argument to enforcement. The Independent Communications Authority of South Africa, the telecoms regulator, issued SpaceX with a formal notice of non-compliance on October 14, 2026, demanding that it stop the unauthorised provision of Starlink services in the country. The regulator had been investigating suspected unauthorised Starlink operations since 2025, after South Africans bought kits registered in neighbouring countries where the service is licensed. Starlink has never been licensed in South Africa, and the regulator has said it has not received a licence application from SpaceX at all.
Starlink has tried to meet the empowerment rules without selling equity. In a letter dated June 14, 2025, to Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau, Starlink executive Ryan Goodnight proposed an Equity Equivalent Investment Programme under which the company would fund satellite kits and internet service for more than 5,000 rural schools, reaching about 2.4 million pupils, plus solar power, devices and software, valued at about R500 million. The company said it had "never sought an exemption" from empowerment law and pointed to similar arrangements used by Microsoft, IBM and Amazon in other sectors. Communications Minister Solly Malatsi issued a policy direction in December 2025 telling the regulator to recognise such programmes — but on May 13, 2026, the regulator replied that it could not apply the direction unless Parliament first amends the Act.
The regulator's position is now being tested in court. Business organisation Sakeliga filed papers in the Pretoria High Court on November 9 asking the court to set aside the regulator's May decision and declare that the Act does not impose a fixed 30 per cent minimum as a precondition for a licence, arguing the law allows alternatives including equity-equivalent programmes. Starlink operates in 28 African countries, including Nigeria, Kenya, Mozambique and Botswana, but South Africa is one of eight countries on the continent with no launch date at all. Musk, who was born in Pretoria in 1971 and left South Africa for Canada at 17, has said government representatives proposed ways to secure a licence by "pretending that a Black guy runs Starlink SA" — an offer he said he refused on principle.
What happens next turns on the court and on whether the two men ever sit down. The Sakeliga challenge will decide whether the regulator must consider Starlink's investment offer as a lawful alternative to selling a stake, while Ramaphosa continues his Silicon Valley trip looking for technology investment and Musk shows no sign of softening — his latest post makes clear he regards the rules as discrimination, and Pretoria regards them as non-negotiable. Until one side moves, Starlink stays out of South Africa and the 5,000 schools waiting on its free connection stay waiting.