A federal grand jury has indicted West Virginia State Auditor Mark A. Hunt and three others on property theft charges, alleging Hunt schemed to steal multiple properties for a longtime friend and business associate through the improper issuance of tax deeds by his office, and has also indicted Hunt and two others on bank fraud charges over falsified timecards. U.S. Attorney Moore Capito announced the indictments on Monday, November 16, in Charleston. An indictment is merely an allegation, and all defendants are presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. Hunt said in a Facebook post on Monday that he is "innocent of these charges."
For the homeowners in Kanawha and Boone counties whose land is at the centre of this case, the charges strike at the one office that is supposed to protect them: the auditor's office oversees the process by which properties with delinquent taxes can be redeemed, and prosecutors allege Hunt used that power to take nine tax-delinquent properties from their lawful owners and hand them to a friend. The case is about who the tax-deed system serves — the property owner trying to keep a home, or the official holding the pen.
The indictments allege that Hunt, 66, of Charleston, was aided and abetted by three people: David Keith Cole, 57, deputy chief of staff for the auditor's office and office manager of Hunt's private law firm; Frederic Caudill, the auditor's office general counsel; and Robert Lisle Johns, 66, the longtime friend and business associate and special counsel at the auditor's office. Each of the four was indicted on nine counts of theft of property, and Caudill and Cole were each indicted on one count of making materially false statements to federal investigators.
Prosecutors allege Johns was associated with a business entity that sought to buy nine tax-delinquent properties in Kanawha and Boone counties. Career employees of the auditor's office had found that Johns had not complied with the law and that the properties were legally ineligible for deed issuance — but Hunt, who took office in January 2025 after being elected in 2024, overruled them. Over the objections of those career employees, he personally signed and issued deeds for eight of the properties on March 28, 2025, and a deed for the ninth property on June 6, 2025, the indictments allege. Hunt had previously called the matter a "tempest in a teapot" and told West Virginia Watch that Johns was a longtime friend, downplaying any legal issues with the transfers.
The bank fraud charges are a separate scheme. The grand jury indicted Hunt, Cole and auditor's office employee Marie Ann Hoffmann, 66, of Hurricane, alleging that from about May 5, 2025, through at least September 29, 2026, Hoffmann submitted falsified government timecards that counted hours she worked at Hunt's private law firm, Mark A. Hunt & Associates, as state hours. Prosecutors allege she left her state post on Friday afternoons to do paralegal and administrative work at the firm, was paid state wages for it with Hunt's knowledge, and did so after Cole validated and approved her falsified timecards.
The penalties prosecutors outlined are severe: up to ten years in prison, up to three years of supervised release and a maximum fine of $250,000 for each theft of property count; up to five years in prison for making materially false statements; and up to thirty years in prison, up to five years of supervised release and a maximum fine of $1 million for bank fraud. The FBI and the West Virginia Commission on Special Investigations investigated the case.
The political response came in the same breath as the charges. House Speaker Roger Hanshaw, a Republican, said the serious allegations cast a long shadow over the auditor's office and its role in maintaining the integrity of other state and local officials, and said Hunt should immediately resign. The West Virginia Democratic Party also called for Hunt and the indicted staff to resign, while commending U.S. Attorney Capito, the FBI and the Commission on Special Investigations for moving swiftly. Hunt has not resigned, and what happens next is a federal courtroom, where prosecutors must prove what the grand jury has so far only alleged.