Former Queens prosecutor Jim Quinn has warned that the new jails in Mayor Zohran Mamdani's plan to close Rikers Island by 2032 would be too small for defendants facing violent charges — leaving no bed for more than 1,000 of them.
The warning is measured in beds. Former Queens prosecutor Jim Quinn, writing in the New York Post, counted 1,433 detainees facing murder charges and 2,625 more accused of other violent felonies, including attempted murder and rape — 4,058 people, nearly the whole planned system. About 1,100 more are sentenced, held for parole violations or awaiting transfer — a shortfall of about 1,058 beds for murder and violent-felony defendants.
Quinn does not claim automatic release — his figures show the gap between today's population and the replacement jails' capacity. The correction officers' union called a fixed cap "ill-conceived, irresponsible" and warned the city "cannot keep the jail population at around 4,100 without irresponsibly releasing individuals who committed violent felony charges."
City Hall says the population can fall safely. Closure chief Dana Kaplan said fewer people in jail is possible, and former Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman said: "There aren't going to be criminals walking the street." Quinn: the same measures have been tried for years without the reductions the plan needs.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani on Friday unveiled the city's first comprehensive plan to close Rikers Island, ending all incarceration on the island by the end of 2032 and moving the people held there into four smaller jails in Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens and Manhattan.
Why it matters: most of the roughly 6,600 people on Rikers have not been convicted of anything — they are awaiting trial, many for months, in conditions federal monitors have documented as violent and unsafe. For them, the plan means being held near the courts and their families instead of on an island; for the city, it means fewer people locked up before trial and cases that move faster.
"It is time to finally close Rikers Island," Mamdani said. His plan, he said, puts the city "on a path to deliver just that: closing Rikers, reducing pretrial detention, tackling the case delays that deprive people of their right to a speedy trial and investing $146m in the evidence-based supports that helps break the cycles of incarceration."
The hard part is the calendar. City law, passed in 2019, already requires Rikers to close by August 2027 — and the city admits it will miss that deadline. Under the new timetable the Brooklyn jail opens in 2029, the Bronx and Queens jails in 2031 and the Manhattan jail in 2032. Demolition starts in 2027, with the North Infirmary Command, opened in 1932.
The arithmetic is just as hard. The four new jails hold about 4,500 people, so the plan depends on cutting the jail population to no more than 5,500 by 2029 and 4,100 by the end of 2032 — through diversion and supervised-release programmes, a restored online bail-payment system, fewer case delays, and hundreds of therapeutic beds for the seriously mentally ill.
Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards said the department is committed to closing Rikers and replacing it with borough-based jails. The obstacles are plain: the jail population has risen since 2020, the new jails are years behind schedule, Elizabeth Glazer, one of the chief architects of the original closure plan, has publicly parted with the approach, and former Mayor Eric Adams opposed the borough jails.
What happens next: the plan must go to the City Council to be written into law, alongside the federal remediation manager overseeing Rikers, and the island's future — long discussed as a green-energy hub — is still to be decided.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here