First posted on Instagram · @profilopolitics
Canada and the European Union have dropped the idea of offering Canada "associate member" status in the 27-member bloc, replacing it with softer language promising an "ever closer association" ahead of the EU-Canada summit in Montreal on October 29 and 30, according to the latest version of a draft joint statement seen by POLITICO and Reuters.
The change came after Germany, France, Italy and Greece objected to mentioning associate membership in the joint declaration. The objections were raised before the deadline of the EU's silence procedure — under which a text is adopted automatically unless a member objects — and stopped an earlier draft from advancing unchanged on October 27, forcing a rewrite.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen first floated the idea of Canada becoming the EU's first associate member in her State of the European Union address on September 16, with Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney in attendance as guest of honour. The proposal caught several capitals off guard: diplomats said the Commission had not consulted member states before von der Leyen made the offer, and the term has no established legal meaning under the EU treaties.
An earlier draft had committed both sides to define "the concept of Associate Member" by the 2027 EU-Canada summit. The revised text instead pledges to define "the concept of an ever closer association of Canada to the EU, short of full membership itself," and to create "an even closer association between Canada and the EU." The text still needs final sign-off from member states, and officials plan to make the declaration public on Friday.
Germany emerged as the fiercest opponent of the term, pressing for its removal on the grounds that it has no legal status and had not been fleshed out. One diplomat told The Telegraph that for Germany "it was personal": Friedrich Merz had floated associate membership for Ukraine, which died immediately. France and Greece also voiced reservations, while Italy's objections focused largely on a separate passage on competitiveness and technological sovereignty, whose suggested wording was accepted.
The resistance centres on uncertainty. Diplomats told Euronews the term was "unknown terminology" that could create legal confusion and raise expectations among other countries outside the bloc seeking closer relations with the EU. Five EU diplomats said governments broadly support stronger ties with Canada but want the legal meaning and practical implications clarified before endorsing the concept in a major joint declaration.
Carney, who is hosting the summit in Montreal, told reporters on Tuesday that the meeting is the launch of further formal negotiations that will take another year. "The good news is it doesn't matter about specific names or nomenclature," he said. "What matters is the difference it will make to the lives of Canadians."
Deeper ties to Europe are an important part of Carney's strategy to reduce Canada's economic and security reliance on the United States since President Donald Trump imposed tariffs on Canadian imports. Trump previously called the EU's associate-member proposal "laughable" and said that if he interpreted the move as a "hostile act," the US might stop trading with Europe "on many things."