Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed Romanch's Law on Thursday in City Hall's Blue Room, ending New York's horse-drawn carriage industry after 150 years — no new licenses, every existing license expires on May 31, 2028, and the carriages come off the streets on June 1, 2028, making New York the largest American city to ban them.
Why it matters: this is the mayor asking New York to trust his judgment — and pointing to his record for why. Mamdani inherited a budget gap of more than $12 billion and closed it to zero, delivering a balanced $125.8 billion budget with the Council, no property-tax raise and no service cuts. "We have closed the gap entirely, down to zero," he said. "We have balanced the budget." A mayor who did the hard work on the city's money has earned a hearing when he says a tradition no longer fits the city.
The law carries the name of Romanch Mahajan, 18, a visitor from India who died on June 17 after the driver stepped away for a family photo, the horse spooked and bolted, and the carriage tipped in Central Park. The Council passed the bill on October 22 by 40 votes to 7, sponsored by Council Member Christopher Marte; Speaker Menin and former Mayor de Blasio stood with him.
The same day, the drivers' union, TWU Local 100, sued in federal court with a medallion owner and two drivers — Chiarello v. City of New York — calling the law "an unconstitutional abomination": a licensed trade wiped out, owners left holding medallions they can no longer sell, no guaranteed payment. City Hall answers that about 200 affected people will be supported through medallion buybacks and a new Horse Carriage Worker Industry Program with job training and tuition help, under a transition plan due April 1, 2027; the law itself only requires the city to consider compensation.
The horses are protected on the way out: by June 1, 2027, owners must certify none will be sold for slaughter or to another carriage operation. Next come the federal court's answer to the union, and a transition plan that will show whether the mayor's promise to the drivers holds up as well as his balanced budget.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here