First posted on Instagram
Vice President JD Vance has pushed back against Oklahoma Gov. Kevin Stitt's call for bipartisan immigration reform, warning that the proposal could be read as an attempt to grant amnesty to people who broke immigration laws. "To a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty to people who have broken our laws. It is morally and electorally disastrous," Vance wrote on X on Thursday, in a post responding directly to Stitt's interview with POLITICO. He drew a distinction: he is open to reforms that make it harder for big companies to defraud the visa system and for employers to violate immigration law — but not to a deal that creates a pathway to amnesty.
The split matters because immigration is the issue that divided Republicans after the midterm losses — and the one President Donald Trump himself has now put on the table. Trump said on election night that he could work with Democrats on immigration, and his Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin has since confirmed that Trump told him to work on a deal with Democrats, while insisting amnesty is not on the table. Stitt is now the most prominent Republican governor pressing for that deal, with a specific proposal: let governors issue workforce permits to immigrants whose employers vouch for them. Vance's answer draws the line for the party's right flank: enforcement first, no amnesty — and he is framing it as a warning about the next election, not just the next bill.
Stitt made the call in an interview with POLITICO on the sidelines of the National Governors Association's New Governors Leadership Forum in Utah, published on Thursday. "We need to have a strong border. We need to know who is coming into our country. We need to vet those people," Stitt told POLITICO's Samuel Benson. "He can lead on this, he can fix this immigration policy." His proposal, which he has pressed since February as chairman of the governors' association's immigration task force: "If an employer is vouching for an employee, the state governors should be able to issue that workforce permit. Period, end of story." Stitt described Trump as a "business person" who "understands the need for a workforce," and blamed Congress for standing in the way of reform.
Vance answered by quote-posting POLITICO's clip of Stitt. "I like Kevin, but what does 'bipartisan immigration reform' mean? If you mean making it harder for megacompanies to defraud our visa system, great. If you mean we should pass legislation to make it harder for employers to violate our immigration law, I'm all ears," he wrote. "But to a lot of people, this sounds like an effort to give amnesty to people who have broken our laws. It is morally and electorally disastrous."
The disagreement sits inside a wider argument in the administration itself. Trump floated a deal with Democrats on immigration on election night, telling Fox News "we can work with them on immigration," and later said he was open to legal status for longtime hotel and landscaping workers — while a White House official told the Daily Caller the administration "will never allow for mass amnesty." Mullin, the Homeland Security secretary, has said a deal could look at legal permanent status for Dreamers, but "we're never going to allow amnesty to happen." Vance's own position has been consistent since the day after the midterms: on November 4 he warned that "establishment politicians" would sell amnesty as the cure for the party's losses — "anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you" — and said he was open to changing enforcement by focusing on businesses that hire illegal labour. His reply to Stitt repeats that line almost word for word.
Stitt is not a newcomer to the argument. As chairman of the National Governors Association he set up a task force on immigration policy, and in a February interview with NPR he said it would be "devastating" for Oklahoma if every worker without legal status disappeared tomorrow. In January he joined Maryland's Democratic Gov. Wes Moore in a joint statement calling for a "reset" of federal immigration enforcement after two killings by federal agents in Minneapolis, and last week he told POLITICO that Trump had "softened" on immigration and could lead a deal with the incoming Democratic Congress. He is term-limited and has said he intends to return to the private sector next year — the reform push is his closing argument as governor.
What happens next is whether the disagreement stays a war of words or becomes a fight over a bill. No immigration bill is on the floor, and Congress does not return with a Democratic majority until January 3 — but the Dignity Act, the bipartisan bill pairing enforcement with legal status for long-term undocumented immigrants, lost several Republican co-sponsors on election day and remains the only vehicle on the table. Vance's post makes clear where the vice president will stand when it comes back: enforcement, yes; amnesty, no — and any Republican who signs on to the other side should expect to hear about it.