Judge Amir Ali has ordered the Executive Office of the President to turn over the drafts, memos and emails behind Donald Trump's executive orders against law firms — or formally claim privilege for them. The order, issued on Monday in the American Bar Association's lawsuit against the White House, covers the period from February 13 to April 18, 2025, the weeks in which the administration issued five executive orders stripping firms of security clearances, barring them from federal buildings and cancelling their government contracts. Ali said the drafts "may shed light on the government's motivation" and the memos "could establish the existence of a policy of intimidation" — the core of the ABA's claim that the orders were designed to punish firms for the clients they represented.
The order quotes the White House's own words back at it. In April 2025, press secretary Karoline Leavitt told the Wall Street Journal that "President Trump's policy team is executing on his directive to hold Big Law accountable for their weaponization of justice and their lies, and the strategy has proven tremendously successful." Ali noted that the administration has refused to name the members of that policy team, citing presidential communications privilege, and that its only other public account of how the orders were written came from a former White House official who told reporters the process "wasn't like anyone was sitting around with a legal memo." The administration has argued in court that the ABA's document requests would disrupt the work of the Executive Branch and raise separation-of-powers concerns.
The background is the campaign the orders launched. In March and April 2025, Trump issued executive orders against Perkins Coie, Paul Weiss, Jenner & Block, WilmerHale and Susman Godfrey — firms that had represented his political opponents or worked on cases he disliked. Four of the firms fought the orders in court and won. Nine others cut deals instead, promising about $940 million in pro bono work for causes the administration favours. Documents the Justice Department has already produced show aides rushing to lift the sanctions on Paul Weiss at Trump's direction, days after the firm agreed to the deal.
What happens next is on a clock. The White House must produce the documents, or claim privilege, and agree search terms and a schedule by December 4. Ali has already rejected the administration's bid to throw the case out, in March, and last month he rejected the Justice Department's bid to disqualify Susman Godfrey from representing the ABA. Leavitt left the White House at the end of August and is now a Fox News contributor. The incoming Democratic Congress has said it will scrutinise the nine firms that cut deals — and Ali's order means the paper trail behind the orders may now be produced in court before Congress starts asking for it.