First posted on Instagram
Justice Samuel Alito warned on Monday that a campaign to intimidate the Supreme Court — and, failing that, to damage its standing and then alter its composition — could leave the institution "fundamentally changed for many years — and perhaps permanently." Alito issued the warning in his keynote accepting the American Enterprise Institute's Irving Kristol Award at the National Building Museum in Washington, saying the Court may soon face the question of whether it will be allowed to continue as an independent tribunal.
The warning lands weeks before Democrats take control of Congress in January after their November 3 midterm wins, and some in the party have proposed expanding the Court from nine seats to 13, imposing 18-year term limits and an enforceable ethics code. Supporters of nine seats say the Court's independence must be protected; expansion advocates say reform is necessary — and whatever Congress decides will shape rulings reaching every household.
"What we have seen in recent years is a mounting campaign to change the direction of the Court's decisions by intimidating justices or, if that fails, by seriously damaging the Court's standing in the eyes of the public and then altering the Court's composition," Alito said, according to the institute's published transcript. He added that what may matter most is popular support for an independent judiciary.
Alito did not name a specific proposal or lawmaker, according to The New York Times, which first reported the speech. Representative Al Green has filed a bill to expand the Court to 13 seats, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse has proposed term limits, and Representative Hakeem Jeffries, expected to become Speaker, has said Democrats must "clean up the mess at the Supreme Court." But no expansion bill has been announced by the incoming majority, and no Democratic leader has committed to a seat count.
It was not his first warning in recent weeks. On Fox News Sunday on October 4, he said there had been "a concerted effort to intimidate the court" to influence how justices decide cases. And at the Federalist Society's Scalia Memorial Dinner last week, he warned separately that Congress could "turn off the lights" at the Court by cutting its funding.
Alito, 76, has served since January 2006 and says he intends to stay through the end of the term next summer. Whether any court bill moves will become clear after the new Congress is seated in January.