Rep. Seth Magaziner used Tuesday's House Homeland Security oversight hearing to walk DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin through the Biddeford case, name by name: on July 13 in Biddeford, Maine, Johan Sebastián Durán Guerrero "was shot and killed by an ICE agent in front of his wife and his three-year-old daughter" — a man who "had just pulled out of his driveway to go to work and was not the person that ICE was looking for." The agent who killed him, David Brouillette, had been hired and put on the street before his background check was finished — under Kristi Noem's DHS.
Why it matters: deportation was the promise at the centre of the President's campaign — remove the criminals, do it properly, and the country backs it. Every case like Biddeford burns that backing. When the man killed is not the target, not a criminal, and the agent who shot him should never have passed screening, the public does not blame the idea — it blames the people who ran it, and the damage lands on the President who promised it.
Magaziner laid out what the finished check would have shown: Brouillette "had severe mental illness, had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder and hospitalized multiple times," and "both of his ex-wives, his mother, and multiple former employers found him to be violent and unstable." His words: "The Trump administration made him an ICE agent, put him on the street with a mask and a gun before the full background check had been completed." Brouillette had also been authorised to use lethal force after only an online course — "he didn't even do any of the in-person training in Georgia."
Magaziner questions Mullin at Tuesday's oversight hearing: "The Trump administration made him an ICE agent, put him on the street with a mask and a gun before the full background check had been completed."

Mullin did not defend the old system — he disowned it. Every ICE agent in service today "has had full background checks," he testified; those without are on administrative leave. The full 13-week in-person training is restored, and those who have not completed it are off the street too. Then the line that pointed the finger where the owner of this headline points it: "Unfortunately, Congressman, there were some decisions that were made before I was secretary that we were having to undo." Mullin has been in the job about 280 days; the decisions he is undoing were Noem's.
The family's account widens the gap the hearing exposed. Guerrero, a Colombian national of about 25, held work authorisation issued in May 2025, a Social Security number and no criminal record, with an immigration hearing pending and no final removal order; DHS first called him an "illegal alien" who entered in September 2023, then confirmed the work authorisation while saying it does not confer full legal status. ICE says the agent fired fearing for public safety as the vehicle tried to flee; the family disputes that account, and one of the bullets struck the child's empty car seat.
The contrast is the whole story. Deportation done with finished checks and full training is the policy voters backed; deportation done the Noem way — agents rushed onto the street unchecked — produces Biddeford, and Biddeford produces hearings like Tuesday's, with the President's own secretary cleaning up decisions he says were made before him. Mullin says the cleanup is real: 517 training classes running, the standards restored. What happens next decides whether the concept survives its managers — the investigations into Guerrero's death are still open, and every agent hired in the shortcut era is a case waiting to be checked twice.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here