The Department of Homeland Security's own watchdog has found a cascade of problems in how ICE trained the 10,000 new officers rushed onto the street during Kristi Noem's hiring surge. In a 19-page draft report, officials describe widespread gaps, and one academy instructor calls the result a “catastrophic failure.” More than 3,500 experienced recruits were put on online courses — a month’s in-person training — and some finished in less than a day.
It matters because those officers carry guns and make arrests in American communities. An officer never properly trained or checked is a danger to everyone he meets, immigrant or citizen — and every bad arrest hands deportation’s opponents another reason to shut the programme down. The shortcuts were meant to speed deportations up; they put the programme itself at risk.
The draft describes recruits sent out with identities not properly verified, and people hurt in encounters with undertrained officers — among them U.S. citizens.
The people who ran the training said it first. In February, ICE academy instructor and agency attorney Ryan Schwank resigned and told a Senate forum the programme was “deficient, defective, and broken”: 240 hours had been cut from the 584-hour course, and the legal classes on use of force — when an officer may lawfully kill — had stopped.
ICE academy instructor Ryan Schwank, who resigned in February 2026, tells a Senate forum the training was “deficient, defective, and broken.”
In September, a 17-year ICE veteran who oversaw background checks complained that job offers went out before fingerprint, identity or credit checks were done. In October, three senators demanded Secretary Markwayne Mullin pull every surge hire from field duty until retrained and re-vetted.
October 5, 2026: Senators Booker, Blumenthal and Padilla demand Secretary Mullin pull every surge hire from field duty until retrained and re-vetted.
Mullin has already told Congress he is undoing decisions “that were made before I was secretary.” Senator Richard Blumenthal, whose subcommittee heard Schwank, says the draft proves the warnings right and promises answers, compulsory measures if needed.
It is a draft, not the final report, and DHS has not answered it in public. What the final report forces — retraining, re-vetting, officers pulled from the street — is the fight now.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here