First posted on Instagram
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani refused to "walk through the math" of his plan for five government-run grocery stores when pressed at the New York Times DealBook Summit on Wednesday, November 18, telling host Andrew Ross Sorkin that when society decides something is necessary for the public, "then we subsidize its creation and its operation. We have determined this is necessary."
The exchange goes to the question every New York household will feel at the till: the stores promise a core basket of everyday groceries at 30% below retail prices, but grocery stores typically earn only 1% to 4% on what they sell, so the discount has to be paid for somewhere — and the city's own documents say taxpayers will cover the gap through subsidy payments while the stores pay no rent and no property taxes.
Sorkin put the arithmetic to him directly, noting the industry's thin margins and asking how a 30% discount could work at all. Mamdani did not answer with figures. Instead, he said food should be treated as a public good, comparing it to the subway, public schools, libraries and sanitation — services, he said, that are "not being paid for at price." He turned the question back on the room: "In some ways, that's the question that New Yorkers are asking themselves every day when they go to the grocery store — 'Explain the math to me of how the same thing that I used to buy a couple of years ago has now skyrocketed in price.'"
The plan, known as NYC Groceries, promises five city-owned supermarkets, one in each borough, with a core basket of fresh produce, meat, seafood and roughly 20 categories of pantry staples sold at 30% below comparable retail prices. The city has committed $70 million in capital funds. The first store is scheduled to open at The Peninsula in Hunts Point in the Bronx by the end of 2027, the second at La Marqueta in East Harlem in 2029, and the sites in Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island have not been named. The city's Economic Development Corporation will oversee the project and contract a private operator to run the stores; the operator will pay no rent and no property taxes, and when discounted prices create an operating deficit the city will cover it through what its request for proposals calls "affordability payments." The city projects the average shopper's total bill will fall about 15%, roughly $90 a month or $1,000 a year.
Critics say the numbers do not add up. E.J. Antoni, chief economist at the Heritage Foundation, said a 30% discount on a roughly 2% margin is "simply a loss for taxpayers who will have to make up the difference." Supermarket magnate John Catsimatidis said he could open ten stores with the $70 million Mamdani plans to spend on five, and industry consultants have predicted the stores will lose at least $300,000 a year. Minority business owners sued the city in August, saying they cannot match taxpayer-subsidised discounts, and grocers warn the subsidised stores will undercut neighbourhood shops.
Mamdani says the stores are for any New Yorker, not only those who cannot afford a supermarket in their neighbourhood, and that he wants the public sector "so good that the people in this room, no matter how much money they may have in their pocket, will choose to use that public sector." His administration notes the plan covers only five stores in a city with more than a thousand supermarkets.
Bids from prospective operators were due on October 16, and the city says it will name operators in early 2027, with the first store to open by the end of that year. The lawsuit from business owners is pending.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here