The City of Charlotte asked a judge on Monday to throw out the wrongful-death lawsuit brought by the family of Iryna Zarutska — and the case it is trying to escape is not really about the man who killed her. It is about oversight. The family's suit says the city paid a security firm $18.4 million to keep its light rail safe and then failed to watch over the work: on the night the 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee was stabbed to death on the Blue Line, there were 11 armed guards across the system and not one of them on her train.
Why it matters: every rider who taps a fare card is trusting that the security they paid for is actually there. Zarutska had paid her fare. The man accused of killing her, DeCarlos Brown Jr., boarded without a ticket, according to the state audit — and no one checked or stopped him. If a city can collect fares, sign an $18.4 million security contract and then claim in court that none of it can be questioned, the oversight itself has no teeth.
The lawsuit, filed in August by Frank Haskell, the administrator of Zarutska's estate, names the city and its transit security contractor, Professional Police Services. It says the contractor was responsible for keeping riders safe, and that the city knew the Blue Line had a violent-crime problem: four homicides in the three years before Zarutska's killing on August 22, 2025. Surveillance video released by the transit system shows Brown sitting behind her on the train, taking out a knife and stabbing her in the neck before walking away.
Surveillance image released by the Charlotte Area Transit System: Zarutska, in the black cap, rides the Blue Line with Brown, in the red hoodie, seated behind her. No guard was on the train.
The money tells the same story, the suit argues. A North Carolina state audit found the transit system planned to spend about $2.23 million on safety and security equipment in 2025 — and spent only about $470,000 of it, leaving roughly $1.76 million unspent and planned security work unfinished.
The city's 34-page motion, filed in Mecklenburg County Superior Court, answers with government immunity. Transit policing, security-contractor oversight and public-safety administration are government functions, the city argues, shielded from lawsuits under North Carolina law — and policing is a duty owed to the public at large, not to any single rider. In the city's own words: "The City recognizes the tragic and devastating death of Iryna Zarutska as the result of an intentional criminal attack by Decarlos Brown Jr. The City denies that it ignored passenger safety or that its conduct legally caused that attack." City attorneys add that systemwide crime statistics do not make an attack on one passenger reasonably foreseeable, and they ask that the claims be dismissed permanently.
The family saw the immunity argument coming and answered it inside their own filing: a transit system that charges fares is acting in a business-like, proprietary role — not a protected governmental one — so immunity does not cover it. That single question is now the whole case. If the judge agrees with the family, the suit goes forward and the city's staffing logs, guard deployments and security spending become evidence. If the judge agrees with the city, the oversight questions end unanswered in court, whatever the audit found.
No hearing date has been set and the judge has not ruled. Zarutska's killing already changed North Carolina law once — it drove the state to pass Iryna's Law, tightening bail for violent offenders and ordering a harder look at transit safety. What happens next in this courtroom decides the other half: whether the people paid to keep her train safe can be held to account for the night no guard was on it.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here