Peter Navarro, now the White House senior counselor for trade and manufacturing, has asked the Supreme Court to overturn his two 2023 convictions for contempt of Congress, arguing prosecutors should have had to prove he knew defying the Jan. 6 committee’s subpoena was unlawful. His petition, filed October 6 and docketed October 8 as No. 26-474, turns on a single word in the contempt statute — “willfully.”
It matters because a win for Navarro would raise the bar for every future contempt prosecution — just as Democrats prepare to take control of both chambers of Congress in January and investigate Trump administration officials. Navarro’s lawyer, Abhishek Kambli, told Fox News Digital that a ruling for his client would make such cases “much harder to prove” and result in fewer prosecutions.
Navarro was convicted in 2023 on two counts of contempt of Congress for refusing to give testimony and documents to the House committee that investigated the Jan. 6, 2021, Capitol attack, saying executive privilege barred him. He served four months in federal prison. The D.C. Circuit upheld the convictions on July 21, 2026, and denied his request for a rehearing on August 28.
The appeals court rejected Navarro’s privilege claim outright. It ruled only the president can invoke executive privilege, and Donald Trump never granted Navarro that protection. Before trial, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta had already ruled in August 2023 that Navarro failed to establish that Trump invoked privilege for the subpoena.
Navarro’s petition asks the justices to go further than the privilege question. His lawyers argue the statute, 2 U.S.C. Section 192, requires proof that a defendant acted willfully — meaning he knew he was breaking the law — and that a good-faith belief he was following the president’s assertion of executive privilege should count. They point to a 1933 Supreme Court ruling, United States v. Murdock, that a taxpayer’s sincere but mistaken belief mattered for willfulness.
Twelve states and several outside groups, including the Oversight Project, the Article III Project and Citizens United, have filed briefs urging the justices to take the case. The Justice Department, now led by Attorney General Todd Blanche, must answer by December 9. The justices have not said whether they will hear the case. In April, the court vacated the appeals ruling against Steve Bannon in a similar contempt case after the department moved to dismiss his indictment.