Sunday, November 22, 2026 — Update
Rahm Emanuel says the intelligence chief's answer does not go nearly far enough. Asked on ABC's This Week on Sunday about Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton's line that Vladimir Putin "is not America's friend in Ukraine," the former Chicago mayor and ambassador to Japan — openly talked about as a 2028 Democratic contender — said the limit was wrong. "That's not an accurate answer just in Ukraine," Emanuel told host Jonathan Karl. "He's not our friend in the Middle East, where we have lost men and women — we lost them because of the technology and the information Russia gave Iran."
Emanuel went region by region. "He's not our friend in the Indo-Pacific, where they just buzzed Japan," he said, calling Japan "the long pole of our national security in the Far East." "He's not our friend in Europe, given the gray-zone attacks. And he is now providing technology to China on the submarines where we have a strategic advantage." He added that Russia is helping build China, Iran and North Korea "a most advanced drone that is beating the defenses there."
Then came the line aimed at the President himself. "The problem here is you have a president who confused his Facebook friend list with our national security," Emanuel said. "And that is not just limited to Ukraine." He argued the friendship framing showed Clayton "doesn't understand the full depth and breadth of what Russia is trying to do to undermine the United States and our security apparatus."
The other side is Trump's own position: his personal channel to Putin is how deals get done. Clayton drew the same line on the programme, calling Trump's "friend" label "entirely appropriate" in the context of last week's three-nuclear-powers summit in Shenzhen, where the leaders met to talk about preventing a nuclear incident — while insisting Putin "is not America's friend in Ukraine. Not at all." Emanuel is now the most prominent Democrat to take the argument further: not a friend in Ukraine, and not a friend anywhere.
— What follows is the story as first written · the update is above —
President Trump's intelligence chief answered on Sunday the question the President himself left open. Asked on ABC's This Week whether Vladimir Putin is America's friend, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said: "He is not America's friend in Ukraine. Not at all. Not at all." In the same breath he defended Trump's own use of the word "friend" for Putin at last week's three-nuclear-powers summit, calling it "entirely appropriate."
Why it matters: whether Washington treats Putin as a partner or an adversary decides the terms on which the Ukraine war ends — how much land Russia keeps, what pressure lands on Moscow, and what American families are asked to underwrite. The man who runs America's intelligence agencies has now drawn the line in public, and the White House has to walk it.
Host Jonathan Karl put the question to Clayton because Trump would not answer it himself. On Thursday, Trump said it is "nice to have people that have 4,000 nuclear weapons as a friend as opposed to an enemy." On Friday, asked whether Putin is a friend to the United States as a whole, Trump said: "I can't speak to America." Clayton explained the summit photograph this way: the three main nuclear powers got together to say "we cannot have a nuclear incident" — and "in that circle of that conversation, using the term 'friend' is entirely appropriate."
Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton on This Week, Sunday — ABC News
Others answered the same question without the careful split. Poland's Prime Minister Donald Tusk said: "Mr Putin is not our friend and will never be." Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, asked the same thing on Thursday, shrugged and walked away. And on the ground nothing has softened: Putin is still demanding all of the Donbas as his price.
Clayton's two answers now sit side by side — friend at the nuclear table, not a friend in Ukraine — and the Donbas demand is where they will be tested. If Putin keeps insisting on land Ukraine has not lost, Washington will have to decide which of its two sentences it means.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here