The full Third Circuit Court of Appeals on Thursday refused to rehear Rep. LaMonica McIver's appeal — ten judges to three, with no opinion — leaving in place the ruling that she must stand trial on charges of assaulting, resisting and impeding federal officers during the May 2025 scuffle at the gate of the Delaney Hall ICE detention center in Newark. She has pleaded not guilty.
This is the case from the oversight visit where Newark Mayor Ras Baraka was arrested at that same gate. The charges against Baraka were dropped. McIver, who arrived with Reps. Bonnie Watson Coleman and Rob Menendez for an unannounced inspection of the 1,000-bed, GEO Group-run facility, is the only elected official still facing charges — and her trial will test how far congressional oversight of ICE facilities can go before prosecutors call it a crime.
Her defence was constitutional: as a member of Congress on official oversight work, she argued, the Speech or Debate Clause shields her from prosecution. District Judge Jamel Semper ruled the shield did not cover her once she involved herself in the mayor's arrest, and in August a divided three-judge panel agreed, two to one, that the physical acts alleged are not protected legislative activity. Judge Thomas Ambro, dissenting, wrote that prosecutors had not cited a single comparable case built on such minimal physical contact.
McIver answered the ruling in her own words: "Now, due to the disappointing decision by the third circuit, we are all one step closer to a world in which the president of the United States can try to imprison people simply because he does not like what they stand for." A grand jury indicted her on three counts; she says the charges carry a potential 17 years in prison. Prosecutors say the gate video shows her assaulting officers as they moved in on the mayor; she says she was pushed and shoved by agents while doing her job.
What happens next: McIver can still ask the U.S. Supreme Court to step in, and her team says it is exploring its options. Otherwise the case returns to Judge Semper's courtroom to be set for trial. Every ruling so far decides only that the case can be tried — not that the charges are true. She is presumed innocent.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here