First posted on Instagram
Representative Abe Hamadeh of Arizona told Oracle chief executive Mike Sicilia to his face on Thursday that the company's contract to rebuild the Department of Veterans Affairs' electronic health-record system — which has grown from a $10 billion deal to a ceiling of $27 billion — is "corporate corruption," and said no further money should move until Oracle and the VA produce a cost estimate accepted by the Government Accountability Office, a fixed deployment schedule and a clear accounting of what has already been wasted.
The money comes from taxpayers, and the scale of it is what drew both parties into the hearing room. House Veterans' Affairs Committee Chairman Mike Bost, a Republican from Illinois, told the Oracle executives the increase works out to "over $2,000 per veteran," adding: "That's a lot of money." Only 19 of the VA's 170 sites are using the new system so far, and the Government Accountability Office puts the full lifecycle cost of the programme at $37.2 billion to get it running everywhere by 2031, with another $19.3 billion to operate it for a decade after that — $56.5 billion in all.
Hamadeh, a U.S. Army veteran who sits on the Veterans' Affairs Committee, said the speed of the rollout is "embarrassing" and that he is "appalled." In the hearing, he asked: "What the HELL has happened? Software for $27 billion. You all should be ashamed. I'm truly — I'm appalled. It's unacceptable, and I REFUSE to be complicit in that." He argued the money wasted on the contract could have "permanently housed every single homeless veteran," and compared the controversy to the fraud scandal in Minnesota. The VA's own count found 32,882 veterans homeless on a single night in January 2024, 13,851 of them unsheltered — a record low, but still tens of thousands of people who served.
Sicilia pushed back, telling the committee: "I'm not here to milk the taxpayers or the veterans. If there are other ways to reduce cost here, my main mission is to deliver the solution for veterans." He said that if the government no longer sees value in the programme, "they should by no means continue to fund" it, and offered to sit with any member of Congress or the VA to "sharpen every single pencil we can." Oracle Executive Vice President Seema Verma told lawmakers the company has "zero access to the data of the veterans" and does not use it to train its artificial intelligence systems — an accusation raised at the hearing by Democrats who said Oracle's sales team had pursued commercial terms on data privacy "which would virtually allow you to own this data."
The VA first contracted with Cerner in 2018 to replace its health-record system for $10 billion over ten years. Oracle bought Cerner in 2022 and inherited the contract. In August 2026 the VA quietly modified it, raising the ceiling by about $17 billion to just under $27 billion and extending it through 2031, without telling Congress first — lawmakers said they learned of the increase from news reports. In September the House committee voted 19-0 to subpoena Sicilia and Oracle chairman Larry Ellison, and Sicilia appeared on Thursday because of that subpoena. Ellison is due to appear under oath on December 10.
Sicilia and Verma told the committee the increase reflects a bigger job than the one first priced: a wider scope and scale, COVID-19 delays, early customisation and inadequate infrastructure. They also testified on Wednesday before the Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee, where Senator Richard Blumenthal pressed Sicilia over Ellison's reported $45 million backing of a nonprofit supporting President Trump's 2024 campaign and the tripling of the no-bid contract. Verma said 40 percent of the original contract's ceiling had already been spent by the time Oracle acquired Cerner in 2022. The hearing also heard that between 1,000 and 1,800 patient-safety tickets are older than 90 days — a figure Representative Nancy Mace of South Carolina called unacceptable from a software company.
The House committee's scrutiny is not over. Ellison's sworn appearance on December 10 will be the next test of whether Oracle can explain the $17 billion increase — and Hamadeh's demand for a GAO-accepted cost estimate, a fixed schedule and a full accounting of the waste now sits with the VA and the company to answer.