First posted on Instagram
Rep. Ro Khanna, the California Democrat, told a gathering of Democrats in Denver on Friday that Americans should "reject this idea of Heritage Americans," declaring, "We are proud of immigrants in this country" — a remark that spread quickly online and drew sharp criticism from conservatives who said it dismissed the multi-generational Americans who built the country.
Khanna made the remark during an appearance at the "What's Next" conference, a post-midterm gathering of Democrats presented by the independent group Majority Democrats in Denver on November 12–13. A 19-second clip of the moment, posted by TheBlaze on X at 8:15 p.m. on Friday, shows Khanna speaking at a podium carrying the conference's "What's Next" branding. The clip had been viewed more than 544,000 times by Saturday morning.
The remark lands in a running debate over what makes someone American. "Heritage Americans" is a term used by those who argue that American identity rests on deep family roots in the country and shared ancestry, rather than on a shared creed alone — an argument Vice President JD Vance recently pressed in a speech at the Claremont Institute, where he rejected the idea that the United States is a creedal nation. Others, including former presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy, have argued the opposite, that Americanness rests on devotion to the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence.
Khanna has taken the second view before. In September and October, he clashed publicly with conservative commentator Dinesh D'Souza after D'Souza defended his daughter's Americanness by pointing to her Christian faith and her mother's race. Khanna, who was born in the United States to an Indian immigrant father, responded by citing an 1858 speech by Abraham Lincoln, arguing that commitment to the nation's founding documents and principles is what binds Americans together, not ancestry or religion.
The clip drew a fast and critical response online. Conservative commentator Benny Johnson reposted it early on Saturday, writing, "Democrats aren't even hiding it anymore. They want you to hate the people who built this country." The account AFpost also shared the clip, describing Khanna as "the son of Indian immigrants" telling Americans to reject the idea of Heritage Americans. Khanna himself does not appear to have posted the clip.
Khanna, 50, was born in Philadelphia in 1976 to parents who immigrated from India and represents California's 17th Congressional District, which includes part of Silicon Valley. He won a sixth term on November 3 with about 71 percent of the vote. He is also a possible contender for the Democratic presidential nomination in 2028: supporters launched a "Run Ro" draft campaign on November 5, and Khanna told reporters at the same Denver conference that he is "certainly considering" a run and will decide with his family after the holidays.
The "What's Next" conference drew a slate of potential 2028 contenders and party leaders, including Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, Senator Elissa Slotkin, Senators Cory Booker, Ruben Gallego, Raphael Warnock and Chris Van Hollen, and former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg. Khanna joined Senators Andy Kim and Van Hollen for a session billed as "The Trust Deficit."