First posted on Instagram
Senator Ron Johnson said on Wednesday that Social Security cannot be fixed and should be shut down, calling the retirement programme a Ponzi scheme in remarks on Fox Business hours before he chaired a Senate hearing on its future. "At this point, there's really no way to fix Social Security. It's a Ponzi scheme. You can't fix it, you just shut it down and hope that you can recover some of your money," Johnson said.
The remark matters because of who said it and where he sits: Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican, chairs the Senate Budget Committee, which held a hearing on Wednesday titled "Social Security: The Reality" on the programme's outlook. About 75 million older Americans, their children and disabled workers receive Social Security each month, and the programme's trust funds are projected to be exhausted in the mid-2030s, after which benefits would be cut unless Congress acts.
Johnson has used the phrase before. He called Social Security a "legal Ponzi scheme" at a Senate Finance Committee hearing on August 5, 2026, saying "that's exactly what it is," and used the same description on a Wisconsin radio show in February 2023. On Wednesday he went further, saying the system should be shut down rather than repaired, and arguing that payroll taxes were spent as they came in rather than saved, leaving only accounting entries behind the promises made to workers.
Democrats seized on the remark. The Senate Democratic Caucus has collected Johnson's past descriptions of the programme alongside those of other Republicans who have called for phasing it out, and argues the programme has paid every benefit for 91 years and can pay full benefits through 2035 even if Congress does nothing. Defenders of the programme also note that it is not an investment fund but a pay-as-you-go insurance system, and that its trust fund holds about $2.85 trillion in Treasury bonds.
What happens next is the hearing itself: Johnson's Budget Committee heard testimony on Wednesday on the programme's finances, and the question for Congress is whether it moves to shore up Social Security's funding or leaves the 2030s shortfall for a later Congress to face.