First posted on Instagram
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said in Manila on Wednesday that he does not believe Washington faces an imminent threat from an alleged Iranian dirty-bomb plot, and used the question to attack the unnamed intelligence sources behind CNN’s report of the plot, calling them “liars” and “liars and criminals.”
The exchange matters because it goes to two things at once: whether Americans should fear an attack on the capital, and whether the public should trust the anonymous sources behind alarming intelligence reports. Rubio’s answer was to tell the public to distrust those sources, while CNN’s report rests on seven serving U.S. officials who spoke to the network.
Rubio was speaking to reporters travelling with President Donald Trump at the Solaire Resort in Manila, after a reporter asked whether he had any intelligence about the CNN report. “First of all, if I had intelligence, it would be intelligence. It would be classified,” he said. “These people that go around just talking about stuff. Let me tell you guys something. Some of your intelligence sources are liars. Others are liars and criminals.” He drew a line between two kinds of sources: “They’re liars because they’re making up — they’re arguing they have access to something they don’t. But, because they have an email address in the government, they somehow have credibility with you.” The second kind, he said, are “liars who are criminals because not only are they making things up, but maybe it’s half true, but they are sharing intelligence information the way they shouldn’t be.”
CNN reported on Monday, citing seven U.S. officials, that American intelligence had picked up signs of Iranian planning for a possible attack on senior Trump administration officials in Washington, using a dirty bomb — ordinary explosives combined with radioactive material — or chemical weapons. Rubio said he was not speaking about that report in particular, but about the practice in general, and declined to comment on the report itself because he did not know who was leaking the information to journalists.
The other side answered in the same breath. Trump said on Tuesday that the United States is “looking into” the report and warned that any such move would trigger an extraordinary response. Iran’s foreign ministry denied the allegations on Tuesday, calling them baseless, and Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi accused pro-Israel media of spreading propaganda to build support for a conflict. Critics of Rubio’s attack argue that anonymous sources can play an important role in exposing information a government would rather keep private, and some users on X called his answer “word salad” for offering reassurance without information.
Rubio closed the exchange where he opened it: “They’re either showboats and liars and probably criminals if they’re saying anything that’s even half true.” He added that the United States is always on the lookout for anyone who tries to do harm to the country, that threat reports arrive every day and most turn out not to be credible, though each one has to be followed up — and that he has confidence in the intelligence services and the systems that identify threats ahead of time. The remarks came at the same Manila briefing where Rubio told Americans the country is “not under systemic attack” after a week of unrelated technology failures.
The report itself remains unconfirmed, and the administration says it will keep following up every threat stream as it arrives. What happens next turns on whether any further intelligence surfaces: Rubio has said there is no imminent threat, and the White House has said it is looking into the report.