Chuck Schumer is losing the Senate. Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan announced in a video on Thursday that she will vote for Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland to lead the Senate Democrats — not Schumer, who has run the caucus for nearly a decade and is fighting to keep the job when Democrats take control of the chamber in January. "Because I've been clear that I won't be supporting Schumer, I will be supporting Chris Van Hollen," Slotkin said. "The American public want a new generation, and they want big and bold ideas. I've been clear as well that I don't think that Sen. Schumer is best positioned to be our next leader."
Why it matters: the Senate majority leader decides what the Senate votes on — the floor calendar, the order of business, which fights get taken up and which never reach a vote. Democrats won control of the Senate in this month's midterms, and on December 1 the caucus picks its leader by secret ballot. Whoever wins will run the chamber from January, starting with a government funding deadline on December 11. Slotkin's defection matters because of who she is: Schumer himself picked her last year to deliver the party's response to President Trump's joint address to Congress — his own chosen rising star is now publicly working to retire him.
Slotkin framed the move as the lesson of the midterms themselves. She said the American people spoke "loud and clear" for sweeping change and the country cannot afford "small nibbling at the edges." She pointed to former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi as the model — a longtime leader who limited her own time at the top and handed off successfully to the next generation — and noted she had spent months saying any candidate for leader had to present a vision for the party's first 100 days in power. Van Hollen, she said, encouraged her by getting in the race. He answered her endorsement the same way: "The American people spoke, and we need new leadership in the United States Senate."
The numbers show a leader whose grip is slipping in public, whatever the private count says. Slotkin is the third sitting senator to go public for Van Hollen, whose six declared backers include Sen. Bernie Sanders and Sen. Jeff Merkley. Van Hollen says roughly 15 Democrats back him privately but will not say so openly — he argues some colleagues fear political retaliation for crossing Schumer. Other incoming Democrats are keeping their distance from the leader without joining the challenger: Kansas Sen.-elect Adam Hamilton reaffirmed his pledge on Thursday, "I will not be voting for Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader," while declining to name Van Hollen. Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017, still counts more declared supporters — over a dozen — and brushed off Slotkin's announcement outside the Capitol with three words: "We've got the votes." Earlier in the week he told reporters, "I'm confident I'll be the next leader."
The contrast between the two men is now the race itself. On Thursday Van Hollen also threw his support behind a bipartisan package of Senate rules changes, written by Sens. Steve Daines and Jeff Merkley, that would limit a leader's power to block committee-approved bipartisan bills from reaching the floor — a direct pitch to senators tired of one office controlling the chamber. Schumer has not endorsed the changes. Slotkin, widely seen as a possible 2028 presidential contender, stood with Sanders at a news conference last week calling for new blood at the top; neither ran, and on Thursday she put her vote where her argument has been for years — on getting a new generation of leadership into the Democratic Party.
What happens next is decided in private: a closed-door, secret-ballot vote of the Democratic caucus on December 1. Because the ballot is secret, the public counts — a dozen-plus declared for Schumer, six for Van Hollen, and a claimed 15 private commitments behind the challenger — may not tell the real story until the votes are counted. If Schumer falls, it will be the first time in nearly a decade that Senate Democrats have chosen a new leader, and the man who replaces him will owe the job in part to the senator Schumer once chose to speak for the party.
📰 ProfiloPolitics Member News — choose your news, share it, earn credit: Join here